CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 2

[thirdgreenham]

I thought 4.0 was a gift grade for that Black Knight... I would have sold it as a 3.0

 

You need to run a sales thread.

 

+1 Got any Black Knights?

[marmat]

Like the previous round, I did great with 2.5 on the DD, and bad with a 3.5 on the BK

It's black or with with me, no grey shades.

[Jeffro.]

I had the Black Knight as a 4.0 and the Daredevil as a 1.8.

 

Those were my grades too.

 

When I reduced the size on the Black Knight, it looked a lot better to me.

 

 

I hope everyone's reading this. (thumbs u

 

Should have gone with my gut.

[toro]

I had the Black Knight as a 4.0 and the Daredevil as a 1.8.

 

Those were my grades too.

 

When I reduced the size on the Black Knight, it looked a lot better to me.

 

I thought the same too. Also I thought the back cover on the Black Knight was very strong, so that is why I bumped my guess upward on that book.

 

I bumped my 1.8 guess on the DD to the 2.0, never thought it could reach the 2.5. But again, that is probably a book that is very solid inside, so maybe that brought it up higher.

[trmoore54]

I had 4.0 & 2.0

 

My grades as well...can see the 5.0 on the B KN but barely...I wouldn't push it past the VG+ personally...but no way does the DD 1 warrant a 2.5. That's a 2.0 all day and a 1.8 before a 2.5...

 

BTW...I don't do well on the super-large scans...I am a much better grader on the regular size. Can someone point out here or PM me how one reduces the scans...I have no idea. Appreciate it! (thumbs u

[Hibou]

Use Firefox and right click the image... choose 'View Image'.

 

(I didn't know that myself until someone posted about it here.)