PGM ALL-AMERICAN COMICS #76

[marvelcollector]

5.5-6.0...leaning toward the higher grade despite TE BC and spine split...

[rjpb]

6.5 all day.

[comicjack]

Welcome that's a lovely old book you have there give it 6.0/6.5 just because of the split .Very nice!

[BarryAllen]

Hi All

 

Thanks again...I appreciate the debate. No hard feelings....I recognize that each collector has their way of interpreting grades.

I've been around a long time....but have just recently got back to collecting comics and trying to understand the CGC way of grading...

A long time I wrote an article on CBM on grading, pre CGC using a coin-like grading system although I never figured they'd actually encapsulate.

I personally like nice front covers even with some spine splitting....and even enjoy restoration copies, of bought at the "right" price. Some issues are completely out of reach for me.....although I once that pretty much everything...nice Action 1, Det. 27 etc....some may remember me for my "find" the Bethlehem collection.

These days I primarily collect dime novels and story papers and other early items, although I still have some of my pulp collection left.

 

I'll be back with some more items when I can find the time....grankids and collecting take up much of it. Also working on a Guide Book for Dime novels

 

Happy hunting to all!

Joe Rainone

 

So, were you in the market to sell the book or slab it? Or just interested in grade perspective?

[storypapers]

I am interested in selling. Fell free to Make an offer...

Otherwise I will probably post sometime next week.

 

thanks, best

 

Joe