D copy or not?

[Lost]

hi everyone....

 

so I recently purchased Uncanny tales #1 CGC 5.0 from a seller and the front cover has not one ...but 2 D's..

 

I got to thinking maybe it's a D copy and began comparing D copies with a D on the front from the same period....

 

Pros-

Looks similar in style to some D's on other books I see from comicbookpedigrees.com under the D copy scans

 

Uncanny Tales was a run in the Crippen D collection with no 1st issue designated for that collection yet (I think?)

 

similar side foxing for other uncanny tales issues i see from that collection

 

Cons-

Why are there 2 D's...

it is not designated as a D copy by CGC if that means anything

 

Is it worth a resubmit? Thoughts?

 

 

 

 

[marmat]

Can you check if there is a code on the first page? Davis Crippen used to write the D on the cover and a code on the inside first page.

 

[Timely]

That book is too late to have writing on the first page. Can you show full front & back cover scans? That would help me better determine if it is or not. If it is a "D" copy, it's not from the recent 2006 find.

[Flex Mentallo]

That book is too late to have writing on the first page. Can you show full front & back cover scans? That would help me better determine if it is or not. If it is a "D" copy, it's not from the recent 2006 find.

 

My first reaction was, it isn't - but West is the man!