Favorite Silver Age hero vs. hero battle issue?

[*paull*]

So what have you? What are your top three favorite Silver Age hero vs. hero battle issues?

[143ksk]

My all time favorite battle issue is actually Bronze Age: The Hulk/Thing battle in Marvel Feature 11 and 12.

 

For Silver Age, off the top of my head, my choices would be:

 

Strange Tales Annual #2: Spidey and the Human Torch

 

Spider-Man #16: Spidey and Daredevil

 

Fantastic Four #25 and #26: Thing/Hulk/FF/Avengers.

[blazingbob]

Giant Size Superstars #1

 

Hulk vs Thing when they are switched.

[*paull*]

Here are mine:

 

1. Silver Surfer #4: Thor vs. The Silver Surfer

 

This has long been my favorite. All-time classic cover, beautiful artwork by the Buscema brothers, and a great Stan Lee story.

 

2. Daredevil #7: The Sub-Mariner vs. Daredevil

 

Classic book... Wally Wood artwork... one of the best of the Silver Age

 

3. Fantastic Four #25: Hulk vs. Thing

 

First Thing vs. Hulk battle... I prefer later work by Kirby on the FF, but this is still a classic issue.

 

__________________________________________________________________

 

Honorable mentions:

 

Captain America #110 (beautiful work by Steranko, but I can't remember how much of a battle this was)

Sub-Mariner #8

Fantastic Four #112

[sfilosa]

All Superhero vs. Superhero books are OVERRATED.

 

 

[*paull*]

Nothing like the first appearance of The Watcher!

[chrisco37]

Another great Battle Cover is TOS #58.

[blazingbob]

Can we please come up with a more original post.

 

How about the worst battle ever done?

 

My vote would be anything with Howard the duck in it or Dazzler or Devil Dinosaur

[chrisco37]

Can we please come up with a more original post.

 

How about the worst battle ever done?

 

My vote would be anything with Howard the duck in it or Dazzler or Devil Dinosaur

 

That's not Silver Age!

[Sharkey]

 

1. Thor vs Hulk in Journey Into Mystery 112

 

2. Thing/Hulk parts 1 and 2 in FF 25 and 26

 

3. Daredevil vs Sub-Mariner in DD 7

 

 

Honorable mention: Daredevil vs Cap America in DD 43 (classic cover too)

[Red Hook]

 

How about the worst battle ever done?

 

My vote would be anything with Howard the duck in it or Dazzler or Devil Dinosaur

 

Don't be a hater Bob,....those were some of the best moments in Marvel History!

 

[Sharkey]

 

How about the worst battle ever done?

 

My vote would be anything with Howard the duck in it or Dazzler or Devil Dinosaur

 

Don't be a hater Bob,....those were some of the best moments in Marvel History!

 

 

 

 

RED HOOK, you are the BEST!!

[Silver Surfer]

For pure art Silver Surfer #4, vs Thor. Story was rather weak.

 

FF# 25 - Thing vs. Hulk, great action and story.

 

JIM #112 - Thor vs. Hulk

 

TTA#100 Sub-Mariner vs. Hulk, probably one of my personal all-time favorites.

 

FF#4 - If this qualifies.

 

TTA#93 Hulk vs. Silver Surfer.

 

FF#55 Silver Surfer vs. The Thing.

[Silver Surfer]

How could I forget Sub-Mariner #8, vs. the Thing? Haven't actually read it yet because its slabbed but what a cover.

[Silver Surfer]

Is FF#112 considered Bronze Age?

[iron maniac]

I have 2 favs:

Tales of Suspense #58 Iron Man vs. Captain America:

 

..and Dardevil #7 Daredevil vs. Submariner(well I guess some might consider Subby a villian):

 

[aardvark88]

Atom 29 or 36 where SA Atom battles GA Atom. GL 59 Guy Gardiner topples SA Green Lantern.

[jbud73]

And the lone DC fan finally comes out of the woodwork. Guy Gardner vs. Hal Jordan.

[uclapeterg]

Can we please come up with a more original post.

 

How about the worst battle ever done?

 

My vote would be anything with Howard the duck in it or Dazzler or Devil Dinosaur

 

I love Dazzler.. not!

[uclapeterg]

 

How about the worst battle ever done?

 

My vote would be anything with Howard the duck in it or Dazzler or Devil Dinosaur

 

Don't be a hater Bob,....those were some of the best moments in Marvel History!