PGM World's Finest 99

[ttfitz]

Bought this at auction, and feel like it was a little overgraded, thought I'd see what the folks here thought.

 

 

[HighStakesComics]

4.5ish IMO. What was it graded at?

[vpcomics]

4.0 for me. That back cover really keeps me from going any higher.

[ttfitz]

4.5ish IMO. What was it graded at?

 

Yeah, I'm about there myself.

 

It was listed as FN 6.0, with no back cover scans. Even with just the front I thought it was generous, so I didn't bid as high as I might for a FN, so I won't be sending it back, but still.

 

Thanks.

[rjpb]

4.0 tops, but if you paid based on it being closer to a 4.0 than a 6.0, it doesn't matter so much what the seller thinks. I have plenty of ebay buys I'm more than happy with, that IMHO were overgraded by the seller, but the scans and description gave me an idea of what I was going to get, and I bid (or offered) accordingly.

[faster friends]

4.5

[ttfitz]

4.0 tops, but if you paid based on it being closer to a 4.0 than a 6.0, it doesn't matter so much what the seller thinks. I have plenty of ebay buys I'm more than happy with, that IMHO were overgraded by the seller, but the scans and description gave me an idea of what I was going to get, and I bid (or offered) accordingly.

 

Yeah, that's about what I think, although I bid a bit more for a 4.0 than I usually would have, less than a 6.0.

 

And I know what you mean about eBay wins, I've had similar. This one wouldn't bother me as much if it had been eBay, but it was a Comic Connect auction, and I kinda expected better.

 

[harvdoss]

4.5