Guess the grade, part II

[namisgr]

Here's another book that was liberated from its plastic prison long ago. Old blue label, no notations, page quality OW/W. I'll post the label for this puppy on Monday. Good luck!

 

 

[awe4one]

9.4

 

Jim

[Aces]

I'd have to agree.

 

9.4

[Ajax]

9.0

[arexcrooke]

9.0

Its a 9.2 at the bare minimum, but it looks like a 9.4.

[nik]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

[greggy]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

[Ajax]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

 

[awe4one]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

 

I agree. Almost went with 9.6 myself until I saw it came with an old label.

 

Jim

[nik]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

Dont you have some sissy romance books to buy or something

[greggy]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

Dont you have some sissy romance books to buy or something

Don't you have POS moderns to list?

[nik]

Even with the very minor flaws to the spine, I cant see this grading lower than a 9.4, but my guess is, it looks good enough to be a 9.6

Dont you have some sissy romance books to buy or something

Don't you have POS moderns to list?

Already did

[davidking623]

9.2

 

Davidking623

[jbud73]

You can see the back left corner is abraided and there is definite over flashing near the top right edge. However based on the scan, which is a tad fuzzy - this book is solid, great gloss and inks, with what looks like minimal to zero surface wear. 9.6 Goin on a limb but even with the old label Unless I'm missing something this blows away that POS X-Men 45 that is still irking me from the first round of the grading contest.

[verygoodplus]

9.4

 

There are some things happening at the lower spine corner that I can't clearly make out, but that steer me away from a 9.6.

[whetteon]

9.2

 

over-hanging on the top.

[jbud73]

Hey Whet, nice to see you posting this week

[whetteon]

[inconceivable]

Great book. 9.4. If this got less than a 9.4 it is definitely worthy of a break-out. Do you do this with all your CGC books?

 

Dan

[Silver Surfer]

Gorgeous book, 9.4.