PGM spidey 60 3 3

[Georgie123]

Hello fellow boardies.

I dont know how to grade these comics

1. The spidey 60 is a very nice book, glossy with tiny spine tics that break the cover. The big issue is the second pic that shows a close up of the top middle cover with a crease. I am presently grading this at an 8

Please give me feedback on how you would grade this.

Edited October 19, 2021 by Georgie123
cannot show 2 comics

[Galen130]

  

One book per thread, please.  Might I suggest posting back cover pics as well?  We like to give estimates based on all areas of a comic…I know I do. 

[Bayowolf]

On 10/18/2021 at 9:47 AM, Galen130 said:

  

One book per thread, please.  Might I suggest posting back cover pics as well?  We like to give estimates based on all areas of a comic…I know I do. 

Ditto

[Georgie123]

so sorry I fixed this. Does it help with the back cover and interior pages

[grendelbo]

We could use a full front cover pic showing all corners and edges. Closer shots by quadrant (top left, top right, etc.) is a bonus.

[Zegeroth]

It looks like you cut out the crease on the front cover pic?  Trying to fool the volunteer graders??? 🤪 What’s on the bottom left front corner??

I think the combo of the spine (particularly by Kingpin’s foot), lower right corner and the top crease takes this to a 7.0.  Just too many small defects for an 8.0.

Edited October 21, 2021 by Zegeroth

[Georgie123]

Thank you for the replies. Now I know better of what pics to send to get a more accurate grade. 

[Mars76]

When posting pics it helps if you take a front facing photo of the whole book, along with the 4 corners and the back of the book.

[Funnybooks]

7.5