Cap 100 i need your p.o.v

[-cryptkeeper-]

i just received this cap , and i'm not really agree with seller grading, give me your pov please thanks !!

 

 

[Pirate]

it looks real close to the 8.0 i have from another black cover cgc book so i'll start there.

[joe_collector]

With the spine creases/smudging and small stain on the back, I'd say 7.0-7.5.

 

P.S. Is that a crease or rip on the bottom-right front corner?

[-cryptkeeper-]

it's a crease

[joe_collector]

So what did the seller grade it at?

[-cryptkeeper-]

8.5 , a professional seller,

[divad]

it looks real close to the 8.0 i have from another black cover cgc book so i'll start there.

 

Are we looking at the same book?

[marvelcollector]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

[divad]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

6.0 Not a penny more The spine wear and creasing makes me even consider lower . . . what was in your cereal this morning?

[-cryptkeeper-]

all right, thanks to you all , i'm going to get in touch with the "professionnal" seller, i will tell you as soon as he answers ...

[marvelcollector]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

6.0 Not a penny more The spine wear and creasing makes me even consider lower . . . what was in your cereal this morning?

 

Apparently a dose of undue optimism...

[joe_collector]

it's a crease

 

Okay, with the crease, I'll lower my guess to 6.5-7.0.

[Comicdey]

it's a crease

 

Okay, with the crease, I'll lower my guess to 6.5-7.0.

 

I concur on the 6.5 side of the estimate.

[Kermit the frog]

even with all the several (small problems) this one shouldn't go below 7.0...still has a very nice eye appeal.

but no way a 8.5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

regards

[B-Smooth]

6.0 tops with all of the spine stresses. It just kills the book being in the green.

[uclapeterg]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

I agree.

[uclapeterg]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

6.0 Not a penny more The spine wear and creasing makes me even consider lower . . . what was in your cereal this morning?

 

What have you been smokin'?

[october]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

I agree.

 

That's a lot of spine stress for a 7.5. I think 6.5/7.0 is more realistic.

[uclapeterg]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

I agree.

 

That's a lot of spine stress for a 7.5. I think 6.5/7.0 is more realistic.

 

Well, we are all in agreement that it's NOT a 8.5.

[october]

Those spine stresses near top on FC probabably bring it down to more like a 7.5 IMO...

 

I agree.

 

That's a lot of spine stress for a 7.5. I think 6.5/7.0 is more realistic.

 

Well, we are all in agreement that it's NOT a 8.5.

 

Yeah, I can agree with that.