PGM X-men #1!

[Aces]

The top spine area is all krapped up but the rest of the book is strong VG.

 

I'd go 2.0.

2.5 maybe...

[marvelcollector]

With that tape and spine split, no higher than 2.0 I'm afraid...

[KingOfRulers]

I'm really suprised by these grades. That's okay--I'll sell it at 3.5 price.

[Comicdey]

I was thinking maybe 2.5....I dredged mine up for comparison....sell it as a 3.5 price.....you want to sell mine at a 5.0 price for me when I'm in Florida??

[KingOfRulers]

I was thinking maybe 2.5....I dredged mine up for comparison....sell it as a 3.5 price.....you want to sell mine at a 5.0 price for me when I'm in Florida??

 

Looking back, I think I undergraded yours. If I were to grade it today I'd say strong 4.5 on yours. Your copy is very clean; I don't know why I graded so harshly last time. For this one I actually held the OS grading guide in my hand for it. I'm sure we could get 5.0 price for yours.

[Shadow]

2.0