• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

ROBTOTHEC

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3,568

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by ROBTOTHEC

  1. ROBTOTHEC
    YEP 9.2 at best.
  2. ROBTOTHEC
    That's a 4.5 in my book!
  3. ROBTOTHEC
    There's a lot going on with that back cover also. I see this at 8.0/8.5. I'm going by recent books I got graded too.
  4. ROBTOTHEC
    5.5 IMHO...
  5. ROBTOTHEC
    It's really hard to tell what is going on along the right edge. Is that a page turning crease or a stain or what?
  6. ROBTOTHEC
    Even with a press you cannot eliminate a color breaking crease. I would never be OK with a cbc getting a 9.6, IMHO...
  7. ROBTOTHEC
    Yes, I would say 7.0 is right on!
  8. ROBTOTHEC
    I would say 3.5 but then it just sounds like I'm copying everyone else! Man you guys are good!!
  9. ROBTOTHEC
    I'm pretty sure that would go in my collection as a 7.0! Unless it appears different in hand it has a lot of positive qualities.
  10. ROBTOTHEC
    We need a bit of a sharper picture but I am seeing 8.5. I don't see a spine roll unless it's VERY slight? Press could result in 9.0?
  11. ROBTOTHEC
    It's got nice eye appeal but a lot of small defects so I would say 6.0 IMHO...
  12. ROBTOTHEC
    I am at a definite 8.5! Nice copy. Yes, that is a printers crease and usually does nothing to the grade.
  13. ROBTOTHEC
    Here's another. I think it was over graded by the seller and I want some of your expert opinions please!
  14. ROBTOTHEC
    I don't see that above a 7.0 IMHO...
  15. ROBTOTHEC
    You are probably right at 2.5 and maybe a shot at 3.0. I would not bother to P&C.
  16. ROBTOTHEC
    Nice book with a 3/4" back cover tear and this large page tear. What are your opinions that page tear does to the grade??
  17. ROBTOTHEC
    Awfully nice 7.5 IMHO...
  18. ROBTOTHEC
    I think it has enough positive qualities and eye appeal that I'm going 4.0. But I could see 3.5?
  19. ROBTOTHEC
    6.0 it is! IMHO...
  20. ROBTOTHEC
    Yeah, 8.0 at best.
  21. ROBTOTHEC
    I'm at 5.5 on this one. Maybe a shot at 6.0?
  22. ROBTOTHEC
    Lot going on with that book. I thought 3.0 before I saw the other graders so I'm there as well! 3.0
  23. ROBTOTHEC
    ALL SIGNED BY SUYDAM!
  24. ROBTOTHEC
    It's hard to tell if this may not be better in hand, but to me it looks 6.5. Maybe a shot at 7.0??
  25. ROBTOTHEC
    This looks like a pretty clean easily 7.5!