Ok, I'll bite. What, exactly, are the other issues that have been raised here?
CGC made a mistake and graded a trimmed book as unrestored. They don't claim to be infallible and I'm sure this won't be the last time they screw up. What matters (to me, at least) is how they act when mistakes like this are brought to their attention and as far as I can tell, they're doing exactly what people wanted them to - admit they made a mistake & try to make the submitter whole.
Apart from Kav's nonsense ramblings, what am I missing here?
The book was graded 3 times (of course I don't know if it was ever graded before I got it) It came back Blue twice and Purple once. Shouldn't the assumption be it's Blue??
That's not the point...the point is making it disappear and go on pretending it didn't happen. Addressing the issue is being swept under the rug. I get it, CGC isn't perfect...but we spend a ton of cash and put a lot of trust in these people...their accuracy is THE most important part of the product they sell. This is a very big deal and puts every graded book into question. This isn't the first time something like this has happened...it has happened to me and many others...CGC can't move forward until they fully address the trimming detection issue. Removing the book from circulation, trimmed or not, does nothing to address it.