travizb

3ish, and I would definitely C&P for a better grade and better presentation.

5 ish

Nice book - 6ish with sub crease

Sweet!  Looks like a sixer to me!

On 9/18/2023 at 7:30 PM, scburdet said:

6.0/6.5. The only thing that might rescue it is being on the reverse, but I can show you books I have with smaller, less noticeable stains on the back at 8.0 & 7.5. They are unforgiving of stains. Does this one reach the inner pages?

It appears that the stain touched several of the inner pages.  I don't have the book in hand or I'd post a few more photos.  I believe 1-2 interior pages have a small sliver of the same residue on them.

Great looking book and slab!

What do you all think this would grade at with the stain on the top left back cover?   Thanks!

8ish

9ish

Page tears and stains on FC/BC:  4/5?

amazing.  6ish.  wish I had one in any condition, let alone this.  nice book.

9

6ish

Good luck and god speed

5.5/6.0

_{Cool book, 5ish}

6ish

8.5/9.0 - Same concerns about the tics on the BC as @morbius21

5ish with detached centerfold

Thanks @scburdet@FoggyNelson@goblinjareth for the estimates.  How does that color rub in the BRFC play into the grade?

7.0/7.5

5.5

5 ish

Looking for some insight on grades pre/post C&P on one of my favorite Batman covers.  Thanks for your feedback!

Sent this question to CGC Customer Service.  Their response:

Quote

Thank you for contacting us. Since we have changed the policy regarding notes mentioning tape, this would be removed from the label upon reholder. The note will most likely be moved to grader notes.