SNiPER

On 9/5/2021 at 4:32 PM, Nic8612 said:

On 9/5/2021 at 4:16 PM, Nic8612 said:

P

On 9/2/2021 at 5:50 PM, zzutak said:

Because the first two interior leaves are also involved, I could see this coming back from Sarasota as a 2.0 GD. 

Ya, who knows what CGC will do! Ive seen CGC 2.5 with 2-3" chunks missing on the cover  at least nothing is missing here and presents well 

Threw it up on the sales thread, will see how it does, need some slabbing money for other funny books in the vault 

Fantastic Four 48 2.5/3.0 ish.

Grade per "PGM forum" consensus : 

4" tear thru Cover, first and second page. (bottom center)

Also book has only one bottom staple, no top staple or staple holes (production error)

Asking  $1200 OBO shipped in the US

 trumps all PM's!

PP, check or MO

10 day return on you unless I missed something obvious.

CGC 2.5 Last sale 8/21 $1450

CGC 3.0 Last Sale 8/21 $2100

Thanks for the responses!

Not sure how CGC will grade this,

the book has a 4" tear thru cover, first and second page, other wise a nice tight well loved lower grade copy. Thanks in advanced!

Payment options?

On 8/12/2021 at 2:04 PM, zzutak said:

Battle #7 (Atlas; Mar 1952).  Copy-A.  Grade = 2.0 GD ow.  Price = $20.
Carl Burgos cover.  Al Hartley, Bill LaCava, and Joe Maneely story art.  Edge chipping and creasing as shown, with no hidden flaws.  Cover and centerfold securely attached at both staples.

On 8/9/2021 at 6:05 PM, Beastfeast said:

Thanks for removing that temptation and grats to both of you on the sale.

Ya, I’ve been celibate on this book long enough

19 hours ago, Nic8612 said:

Clean Fun - $100

Not PCH, but definitely pre-morality codes

 

 

8.0

Looking at the first three pictures I though I was looking at a NM copy of one of my favorite SA key books! Still wondering how those staples got so rusty on a NM looking copy.

Deductions for rusty and migrating staples on a otherwise very high grade SA key comic should be interesting, I'm guessing 4.5 but hoping CGC will go 5.0 in this case.   

3.0

4 minutes ago, JollyComics said:

I hate to say this. It has two major creases on FC.  Let's be safe with 4.5 Q.

Agree, maybe a shot at 5.0 Q

Had the same production flaw

Mine was a CGC 9.6, but I don't think it was because of the production flaw. 

4.5 

maybe 5.5 if pressed and cleaned

2 hours ago, buddy2 said:

Thanks @comicginger1789 I appreciate it.   I am still trying to learn the difference between say a 3.0 and 3.5 thus my question.  I wasn't sure if that tear vs staple pull changed it from a 3.0 to 3.5  or not.  I am trying to guess the grade too when I post and I was above a 3.0 in my guess (just above )  thus wanted to see if that is where I went astray.   Thanks again, I really appreciate your and everyone's insight on this board.  

May not be to CGC standards, but has helped me to grade fairly accurately:) 

All White Pagers? Very nice!

SOLD per PM

That's a beauty! Don't get much better for the assigned grade. 

I would take this book over a 4.5 with marvel chipping anyday! GLWTS!

New Mutants #98 CGC White Pages

Case in perfect shape, notice factory roller scuff mark before you decide to purchase, see closeup.

$300 or best offer, PayPal only, shipped priority flat rate med box in the US only.

 in thread trumps all until I post a "SOLD per PM"

Great buyer, fast payment, smooth transaction. Thanks again Ben

SOLD per PM

Price Reduced to $5500 shipped/insured