Zzutak -
I totally understand what you're saying re: "confidence in the seller" - BUT how much would Heritage Auction's keep? I checked their website and couldn't exactly determine what their percentage is, plus the cost of preparation (grading, cleaning, pressing, etc.) Per Overstreet: at 4.0 = $15,600 and at 6.0 = $31,200. The general consensus puts mine about a 5.0 = $23,400.
Like I said - I'm new to this - but I have done a fair amount of research (Overstreet, E-bay, other comic book sites, local comic book dealers) and now I'm almost thinking that with the time and costs involved in consigning to Heritage - I might be better off just selling it raw to someone local since I live in Seattle (ie: large metropolitan city) and let them deal with it...? Pros / cons to this idea?
Thanks again - I appreciate everyone's honest, experienced feedback!