Jerel and The Case of The Phantom Locke & Key #4 Second Print.
I am a completist with this title, so I have to have two of these for a reason.
It's a little known fact Locke & Key #4 went into second printing and was released on Memorial Day week May 29, 2008. I read this article on artist Gabriel Rodriguez's boards, http://gr-online.blogspot.com/2008/05/locke-key-4-sold-out-too.html, and wasn't surprised to see another heaping pile of Locke & Key #4 books the following week in the new release racks all over New England.
What confuses me is the fact, when I first picked it up, I noticed right away it did not have the usual "2nd Print" indicator on the front cover of a red eye in the IDW symbol. I opened up a copy and it said "1st Print" in the indicia too. I went store to store in the tri-state area, hearing that these were new second prints. I passed on them, because I really didn't want to clutter my set with second prints, and because they all had bent top staples.
Than one day a reputable seller sold me a CGC 9.9 #4 SS book. I have had gotten a CGC 10.0 of #4 already and was at the time building a Signature Series set. When I was comparing the two, I noticed a difference in contrast on the covers, which happens in printing. The first print one I got on May 14, 2008 had a pinker background, but the other one had a lighter background. But then I noticed, the top bent staple. Upon comparing the two, I noticed an entire different staple allignment too. I grabbed my #4 reader copy that day and went out to places all over gathering them up.
When I compare my first print reader copy on the right, to a copy similar to the SS book, I had gotten on the left, you can see a different contrast of background color.
Then you can see different staple allignment between my reader copy on top, to the copies on bottom.
A staple allignment that is common with the "2nd Prints" of this title.
I emailed IDW Publishing twice and they have denied a second print run for this issue. CGC is unable to call it a second print because of it having first print in it's indicia and cannot call it a "Manufacturer Error" variant because it scored a perfect 10.
So if you have one of these "First Print" #4 books with bent staples, staples in allignment of a "2nd Print" and a lighter front cover, chances are you have a genuine oddity in your collection.