Scrooge

Jon, if you don't mind my asking, knowing how extensive your collection is, are there books you are still looking for and acquiring or are you satisfied with your collection as is? Are there some collecting goals you had starting out or decided upon in the meantime that you have still to accomplish (after all those years)? I am asking you because I know once I am done with my March '52 project, there are quite a few other goals that are solidifying in my mind that I hope I can then embark on and I'd like the insights of a "veteran". And I am also asking these questions to others here such as Adam, Fuelman, RHG, 123ksk, tth2, HarveyDude, ... or anyone else. Should we put a limit? such as: only answer this question if you have been collecting for over X years: let's say 20 years. We can relax that if only few of us have been at it this long. Thanks for any answer you can provide.

# 40 Crime Does Not Pay # 108 - eBay purchase Content: The Double-Cross that Boomeranged by Bob Fujitani (signed Fuje) 7.5 pgs Jim Franton, Bootlegger versus Bud Rollings, Con-Man by ? 6 pgs One Thrill Too Many by ? 5 pgs The Case of the Custom-Made Clothes by Fred Guardineer 6 pgs Let's first talk about Bob Fujitani whose career spans such a long period as evidenced by the entry in the Comiclopedia (and the career-long interview in AE 23): "Bob Fujitani studied at the American School of Design in New York City. He has done comics art for a variety of publishing houses from the early 1940s. He has drawn for among others Ace/Periodical House ('Lash Lightning'), Avon (Eerie, western), Dell (adventure and historical comics), Harvey ('Green Hornet', 'Shock Gibson'), Lev Gleason ('Adventures in Wonderland', 'Crime Does Not Pay', 'Two-Gun Kid') and Quality ('Black Condor', 'Dollman'). He has done illustration work for Boys' Life and The Golden Magazine. He has worked as a ghost inker on the daily 'Flash Gordon' comic in the 1960s as well as the 1970s. In the mid 1940s, he also worked on the daily 'Judge Wright' strip. In the 1990s, he worked on the 'Rip Kirby' daily." Most of the online references point to his Dr. Solar, Man of the Atom work as it has recently been reprinted. Obviously his work for CDNP is not his best but that's what we have for today. Considering how important this title was for Crime Comics history, it deserves its own entry in the Toonopedia here but I'd rather direct you to the Crimeboss website where you should navigate to the articles from CBM that are transcribed there if you haven't read them (and instead of me pasting them here) and also to the extensive gallery. Fuje's splash Second Story Page - Can anyone defend the reason behind the panel breakdown on the top tier? Do they serve any purposes? If they do, I miss the point and would appreciate being enlightened. Third Story Splash Guardineer Splash P.S.: At times searching for content I come across interesting sites that are not directly connected with the books but this is something I find amazing. Check out this link to a photographic tour of Bob Hyde's ERB collection and make sure to continue through the three galleries. Simply amazing.

Tim, those are great books for sure and you have every bragging rights. It is still amazing to me that any books survived in that grade in the first place. As you know, even Harry's copies are not all grading that high! Allow me for a small hijack (sp?) of the thread but it seems to me I had seen that guy before or is it its long lost cousin. Is it me or are these very similar-looking?

Will you send this book to me if I pay postage? Pretty please

This one without the Cover error

Duck Lovers Unite and Let Not This Thread Die or else ...

Try to change it to this version and let's see if you think it's better.

# 39 Crime Detective Vol. 3 # 1 - eBay Purchase Content: The Nightwalker by ? 6 pgs Dugan's Leather Joker by Bill Ely 7 pgs The Boiler Comes to Town by Briefer 6 pgs The Stuffed Farmhouse by Paul Reinman 6 pgs Hmmm... tough decision today as whom to profile. Bill Ely had a long career but I don't know anything about him at all. Briefer was still doing Frankenstein so we have opportunity to talk about him, except I don't have my copy of Frankenstein yet. Paul Reinman showed up in Battle Action 1 and I didn't profile him then and who knows if he'll show up again Let me do a poor job on all three then. According to the Comiclopedia, "Bill Ely drew several adventure comics throughout the 1940s and 1950s. For Dell/Western Publishing, he illustrated among others 'Ellery Queen', 'Zorro' and 'Ripley's Believe It or Not'. He has also drawn adventure comcis for DC/National, Centaur, Fiction House, ACG/Creston, Ziff-Davis, Eastern Color, Hillman, Marvel and Charlton from the late 1930s to the 1960s. He has done such superhero comics as 'Rip Hunter, Time Master' and 'The Atom'." A little sketchy on details but could not find better elsewhere, except this discussion online but not knowing the credentials of the author, let's take them with a grain of salt: "Several of [his] stories were reprinted in various DC giants during the seventies and I always thought they looked out of place. Not bad but more illustrative in a way than what I was used to. I guess he really was probably drawing in more of an Alex Raymond influenced style than anything, but there was something kind of squinty and maybe a little watery about his line that kind of stuck in my mind. I said it reminded me a little of Dan Spiegel but it's not really that close of a resemblance. I have seen Gerry Taloac (sp?) use a similiar line at times." Paul Reinman was recently profiled in AE 42 and his Comiclopedia entry (which I link because the panel used for illustration is from today's book) reads "Paul Reinman was an artist of the American Golden Age. He continued 'The Atom' from 1947 to 1949, succeeding the series's creator Ben Flinton and Jon Kozlak. He has done such titles as 'Green Lantern', 'Starman', 'Wonder Woman' and 'Thunder Agents'. His stories also appeared in Crime Detective Comics and Fear. From 1949 to 1950, he did four stories of the daily 'Tarzan' strip. His most notable work appeared in the Atlas war books from 1952 to 1953. For the same publisher, he did religious comics, such as 'The Temptation of Jesus' and 'The Fall of Jericho'. He was Jack Kirby's inker in the 1960s. In 1965, he graphically created 'The Mighty Crusaders' for Archie Comics." As for Briefer, more information is available online, even though as per usual it is wont to be the same information told over and over so for lack of knowing who said it first, here's again the Comiclopedia entry (for which the illustration again is from today's comic): " Briefer (1915 - 1982, USA) Richard "" Briefer went to New York's Art Students League and entered the comic book business in 1936 as a member of the 'Jerry' Iger studio. Briefer's earliest work appearred in 1936 in Helne's 'Wow', one of the first comic books to carry original material. Over the next years at the Iger studio, Briefer produced material and titles like 'Hunchback of the Notre Dame' and Flint Baker' from 1938 to 1941 for Fiction House, 'Rex Dexter of Mars' from 1939 to 1941 for Fox and 'Human Top' in 1940 for Marvel. In 1940 however, Briefer approached the Prize group with the idea to adapt Mary Shelley's 1818 'Frankenstein' to comics. After six years running, the 'Frankenstein' series ended in February 1949, and returned to serious drawing. In March 1954 the Prize group recalled him to revive 'Frankenstein', but the revival ended in November 1954. Briefer left the comic industry shortly thereafter to concentrate on advertising artwork. He died in the spring of 1982." For an extensive look at Briefer's work on Frankenstein, check out last year's Halloween issue of AE. There are plenty of his Frankenstein stories on display online and you can find three here with a short bio and another few here, there and everywhere. Onto the splashes. One thing I liked about the book is that (intentionally or not), the artists made an attempt to reflect the time periods and locations of the stories in their art (at least for the first unknown artist and Briefer). 1910 Paris Bill Ely story Briefer page in 1911 US Paul Reinman's entry OS Guide Pet Peeve: this book, IIRC, is listed as drug cover in the guide (which is true enough) but of course there are no drug stories inside. This is only my second most annoying peeve in the guide. The first one is all the books where Frazetta is mentioned as having work, even if it is only a one-page ad and for which the prices are higher than surrounding issues. Drives me nuts.

Mark, it's funny the timing you have with this thread and you'll see this in a second. First I think you should also investigate how early other media reacted to the mounting threat because that phenomenon has been documented more extensively. This should provide you with some date references as to when the national mood changed. I recommend you check out this review. Without knowing too much, it does seem that the features mentioned in the first part of the review, i.e., the ones released before the war are either short features or associated with UA and Chaplin who played by different rules than the majors so a deeper look would be needed. Also, your timing is perfect as on NPR's Day to Day, on the 5th, they talked about a new documentary AMC is running: Imaginary Witness: Hollywood and the Holocaust which specifically explores the depiction of the Holocaust in television and the movies. You can listen to the Day to Day feature here. And possibly you can still catch the re-run of the show on AMC (which I don't get so I can't see it. Were you to tape it, I'd love a copy). The Day to Day feature, IIRC, mentioned that actually the Jewish power-that-be in Hollywood didn't want to attract attention to their Jewish roots and therefore did not emphasize the horrors taking place in Europe. Plus I remember the mention that monetarily, since 10% of their worldwide take came from Germany, this was not a good business proposition. You can listen to Day to Day to confirm. Relating this to the relative shyness of the moguls versus their counterparts in the comic industry, you have to take into account that the story originators were the artists and scripters who were not: 1) of the same generation as the publishers and also therefore 2) not as well established, read "integrated", in society and thus cared less about expressing their views as opposed to the moguls & comicbook publishers (again, hurry up and read Men of Tomorrow as this is addressed as well) that wanted everyone else to forget their roots. This is a time in America when anti-semitism was overt. We are still a few years away from Gentleman's Agreement which came out in 1947. If people can contribute, this can become a very interesting thread.

As promised

Bob, I'll post the Tomahawk tonight then. Now back to work and to wonder how I missed this Action cover in the Gerbers! No matter how many times I go over those, some covers are simply not done justice in them and that's why we need people to post their books here. This, too me, is a perfect example. P.S.: How did the Little Lulus you mentioned a while ago you won on eBay turn out to be? I remember some brilliantly white covers in the batch.

GP, thanks for sharing. There are no stipulation about condition in this thread. I put my beaters up as well. It'd be great if we could see more of your books. Adam can keep on posting his HG copies. That's OK, we'll let him do that. He's just dangerous because he'll force you and DD to spend more money chasing books he shows us. Are you paid by dealers to post here Adam? Funny you should put up the Tomahawk because I hesitated the other night between a Tomahawk 10 and the Young Eagle. More Tomahawks please if you've got them!

Are you moonlighting off the boards? Webmaster, is Scrooge allowed to do that? Say that's funny because I was thinking of contacting whoever's your boss (if you aren't your own) and ask him to let you off work 2 hours earlier than anyone else so you get online the same time I do in the p.m. It would save me time by just asking you questions instead of looking things up in my books or online. I ordered the Murphy Anderson book by R.C. Harvey almost a month ago but still hasn't showed up I think it's time for an email to the vendor. I go to the gym after work. I have the Anderson book, but there's a large stack I haven't gotten too. He's been extensively interviewed over the years so I wasn't expecting much new stuff for me in the book. My favorite artist appreciation book is Sadowski's Krigstein. For me, it's hand's down the best book produced about a comic artist. It doesn't hurt that I'm Krigstein fan, but I think the book is well written, beautifully illustrated, and impeccably designed.. Yes I agree with you about the quality of Sadowski's book; even though in a sense Krigstein does not contribute much to the field (considering his limited output) and lack of consistency in that output (his story King of the Con Men in All True Crime Cases 49 which I profiled what seems a long time ago is clearly sub-par but this was work for Atlas crime, not what he is best remembered by). My main gripe about the book (and I need to relax as it seems I am getting more and more critical here) was that I wish it would have included a better bibliography of Krigstein's comic work. I have volume 2 also but haven't had the chance to read those stories. You know thinking back over it, we've been lucky lately with the quality of books coming out. By the way, if I remember correctly, a local used book store has a copy of volume 1 either half-price or discounted anyway so if anyone is interested, let me know.

Are you moonlighting off the boards? Webmaster, is Scrooge allowed to do that? Say that's funny because I was thinking of contacting whoever's your boss (if you aren't your own) and ask him to let you off work 2 hours earlier than anyone else so you get online the same time I do in the p.m. It would save me time by just asking you questions instead of looking things up in my books or online. I ordered the Murphy Anderson book by R.C. Harvey almost a month ago but still hasn't showed up I think it's time for an email to the vendor.

# 38 Crime Clinic # 4 - eBay purchase Content Dr. Tom Rogers in The Heart of a Con by ? 9 pgs Barney Bailey in Nobody Cheats the Hangman by ? 7 pgs The Padre in Sidewalk Serenade by ? 5 pgs Dr. Tom Rogers in Big-shot in the Big House by ? 7 pgs Considering I don't know who drew these features, we will concentrate on the cover artist Norman Saunders (I love those pictures of artists posing for their own painting in costume) Or I should have said you will. Norman Saunders' son is running a website dedicated to the life and career of his father at NormanSaunders.com. I recommend you check out the Biography. Remember though that this is a labor of love as exemplified by this excerpt concerning Norm's work in comics so don't be too critical. "At that same time Norm's old publishers also sent him many jobs painting covers for comicbooks. Comics were still evolving in these early years and they often had full color covers painted by pulp artists, and their stories were filled with the same shocking pulp fiction thrills. However, these products were being distributed along with innocent kiddie comics and this shared marketing raised many censorial eyebrows! The fact that Dad's covers looked realistic, made their horror all the more gruesome. Letters of parental complaint led to a public campaign for the government to regulate "the trash we expose our children to!" This is a whipping-horse that still appeals to today's political opportunists. My father's painted covers were so nightmarish that the United States Congress actually passed a Comic Book Code of Decency Act to protect American youth from his kinds of images. How many kids can say that! The legislation was swept along with the general drive to crack down on "unAmerican activities" and by 1954 my Dad's controversial style of work was black-listed from the comics." More relevant for this thread is this link to Saunders Comic Cover Gallery, especially early 1952. I'll let you peruse at your leisure. There is a great in-house ad in the comic. It however sadly reflects on the quick demise of the comic department of Ziff-Davis. Most of the titles listed below had a very brief life, folding generally after less than 5 issues. In case you can't read the taglines, let me repeat them here: Flyboy - Thrilling Adventures of Flying Cadets The Hawk - Fighting Marshal of the American Desert Space Busters - Daredevil Adventures in the Limitless Void Speed Smith - King of the Hot Rods! Thrilling Speedway Action Eerie Mysteries - Journeys into Realms of Fantasy Beanbags - Great new Star on the laugh horizon Explorer Joe - Daring Trail Blazer of new Frontiers Wild Boy - Boldest Jungle Adventurer of them all Crime Clinic - Can crime be cured? Combat it with Dr. Tom Rogers, prison psychiatrist Crudader from Mars - Unearthly visitor from another world Weird Thrillers - Spine-tingling Tales of the bizarre and unusual. Kid Cowboy - Boy Marvel of the Wild West Sparkie - America's Beloved Radio Pixie Ellery Queen - Mystery and Murder with the world's greatest detective G.I. Joe - Exciting battle action with the U.S. Infantry at war Am I hitting the heyday of the period during which Joe Siegel edited the Ziff-Davis line and tried to expand it into a full-fledged comics outfit? Is this why we get "bizarre" concept like Dr. Tom Rogers, Sparkie, FlyBoy, ... ? I don't have time to check but I trust some will enlighten / correct me. You guys have to carry your weight (Seriously work will be busy tomorrow). First Dr. Tom Rogers story Second story splash The Padre as the lead character is a different idea Second Dr. Tom Rogers story Notice the huge irony of the mention in the caption that "This is the hottest thing since Kefauver." Little did they know!

Awesome Rex up there Adam. Do you happen to have a # 2 laying around for us to see?

# 37 Crime Cases # 10 - Bought from Southern California Comics Content: Crime Wave! by Tony DiPreta 7 pgs The Guinea Pig! by Jack Keller 6 pgs Murder Will Out! by ? 5 pgs Mugger at Large! by ? 5 pgs Or maybe the title should have Crime Cases! as there appears to be an incessant use of exclamation points in this issue. We see Tony DiPreta again today but we will overlook him once more (very shortly as he will come back in a few days) in favor of Jack Keller (who will reappear at the same time as DiPetra and more and has already appeared in All True Crime Cases). Note though that Keller is showing up in Atlas books only while DiPetra appeared also in Lev Gleason meaning Tony had to beat the pavement a little harder to manage his accounts. Jack Keller was interviewed by Jon Cooke back in CBA 12 shortly before his death in 2003. I will draw from Doc. V.'s Jack Keller Remembered feature to profile Jack (sorry for the length but this is a nice and concise overview of a 30 years career in the field): "JACK KELLER (1922-2003) The comic book world lost one of its most durable mainstays of the 1950's and 1960's when Atlas/Marvel and Charlton artist Jack Keller passed away on January 2, 2003 at the age of 80 after a short illness. Keller had a long and distinguished career spanning the years 1941-1973 on a score of features for numerous comic book companies but is best known for long runs on two features in particular, KID COLT OUTLAW at Atlas/Marvel and the entire genre of hot rod and racing cars titles at Charlton. Jack Keller was born on June 16, 1922 in Reading, Pa. Except for a short period early in his career, he would spend his entire life there. Like almost every artist from his generation, his earliest artistic idols were Milton Caniff, Alex Raymond and Hal Foster, and as a child devoured their newspaper features, especially Caniff's TERRY AND THE PIRATES. In 1941, fresh out of high school and with no formal art education, Keller created, wrote and drew a comic book feature called "The Whistler" which was accepted for publication by Dell Comics and appeared in the title WAR STORIES, issue #5. By his own admission it was extremely crude but it somehow opened the door to a job in 1942-43 with Busy Arnold at Quality Comics. Among a handful of different features including inking BLACKHAWK, artwork in features llike "Man Hunter" and "Spin Shaw", Keller also did backgrounds for Lou Fine on THE SPIRIT while Will Eisner was in the service. Keller was now living in New York City full time at the 34th street YMCA and his quarters were cramped and tiny. Making the rounds over the next few years, Keller had stops at Fawcett drawing "Johnny Blair", at Fiction House drawing features including marine pilot "Clipper Kirk", "Flint Baker" and "Suicide Smith", and at Hillman on "Boy King", "The Rosebud Sisters" and various crime features. As the decade closes, Keller does work for Charles Biro and Bob Wood at Lev Gleason in CRIME DOES NOT PAY, CRIME AND PUNISHMENT and various Western features from roughly 1949-50. Jack Keller's last two major accounts in his comic book career would be where he'd leave his lasting mark. In 1950 Keller showed up at Stan Lee's Timely Comics doorstep and would begin an association that would last the entire decade. At this point in Timely history, Martin Goodman had just dissolved the long-standing Timely bullpen. Originating in 1941, this was a means for Goodman to save money by weening away his dependence upon the Lloyd Jacquet shop, Funnies Inc. for artwork. Goodman started an "in-house" staff to churn out the scores and scores of features appearing in his comic book line's myriad titles. Known as the "cataclysmic closet catastrophy" (as coined by Stan Lee in his recent "bio-autography"), the story goes that Goodman opened a closet to find a six foot stack of bought but never printed artwork. Going ballistic, he instructed Stan Lee to fire the staff and everyone went freelance. Jack Keller shows up right at this moment and is immediately given work with stories for Western titles, early pre-code horror and even the rare romance story. His most prolific "early" Marvel work though, was in the dizzying array of redundant Timely crime titles . This work is severely overlooked and under-appreciated when one is considering Keller's career. Never a spectacular or flashy artist, Keller's crime stories nevertheless had an urban grittiness perfectly suited to the subject matter with a style similar to that of crime comic collegue Vern Henkel, and two steps above the Timely crime comic bullpen fare of 1948-49. At least 75% of Keller's crime stories were scripted by Carl Wessler, who wrote more crime stories than any other Timely scribe during this period. Often entire issues in 1950-51 were Wessler scripted. Look for these stories in titles like AMAZING DETECTIVE CASES, KENT BLAKE, ALL-TRUE CRIME, JUSTICE COMICS, CRIME EXPOSED, CRIME CAN'T WIN and CRIME MUST LOSE. As 1953 rolled in, Keller added more horror and war stories to his credit but a Western feature that he'd drawn since 1951, KID COLT OUTLAW, began to take prominence. When Stan Lee gave Keller KID COLT in 1951 it was nothing more than another assignment but while other artists came and went on various features (Maneely on BLACK RIDER, WYATT EARP, RINGO KID, WHIP WILSON , THE GUNHAWK, Shores on TWO GUN KID, Romita on WESTERN KID, Roth on APACHE KID, Wildey on OUTLAW KID, etc.), Keller "never" really left KID COLT and drew his adventures both in his own long running title and also in the anthology Western title GUNSMOKE WESTERN, right up to the Atlas implosion in the spring of 1957. Throughout this long run he would continue to do Western fillers but his non-Western work practically vanished by 1955 as his entire output was dedicated to the Western genre. In the spring of 1957 the infamous Atlas Implosion left Keller and scores of artists without their main source of freelance income. Goodman and Lee pared down the bloated line from a high of about 70 titles to a paltry 16, quickly acquiring distribution for the books from National's distributor, Independent News and Stan Lee began to use backlogged inventory for the remaining 8 books allowed per month. Keller, always a tremendous car buff, frantically secured employment at a car dealership in his home of Reading, Pa but almost immediately the Western inventory ran out and Stan called back his Western mainstay artists, Joe Maneely, Jack Keller and Ayers. Keller would return to KID COLT, but time constraints limited his work to a degree. Lee would call back additional Western artists to help out, especially with the tragic death in 1958 of his star artist Joe Maneely, and slack in the Western books was picked up by artists like Jack Davis and John Severin. Within a short time Keller also secured Western and war scripts from Charlton in titles like BILLY THE KID, CHEYENNE KID, BATTLEFIELD ACTION, FIGHTIN' MARINES, FIGHTIN' AIR FORCE, FIGHTIN' ARMY, SUBMARINE ATTACK and others. A long friendship and association with editor Giordano ensued and by 1959 Keller parlayed his love of cars and racing into a long writer/artist tenure on the title HOT RODS AND RACING CARS which lasted, with a short hiatus, until 1973. Keller would also add other hot rod titles over the years like HOT ROD RACERS, DRAG 'N' WHEELS and WORLD OF WHEELS. By 1967 Keller had finally left Stan Lee and Marvel for good and would work nearly exclusively for Charlton until 1973. A handful of concurrent stories from DC in the years 1968-71, including fillers for their HOT WHEELS title, would cap his career and Keller retired from comics and went back to selling cars and indulging his hobby of model cars and die cast car models." Please don't hesitate to navigate to Doc V.'s article as it is illustrated and includes a personal reminiscence by Doc V. I decided to bold one comment in the article and in a few days you'll start to understand why; because we are a long way from being done with the Crime titles and those are only the ones whose titles start with the word Crime! And Goodman was certainly one who put out many of these. DiPetra Splash Keller Splash Unknown Splash - Story 3 Unknown Page - Story 4

You could always liberate the comic from its slab so there wouldn't be any glare I would seriously be no help with your problem as I own zippo slabbed books.

I thought we said no Super I guess I'd have to put up another Western book

Adam - Re: "I'll bet you it's Al McWilliams. The scan was too rough for me to look at so I pulled out a book I've posted earlier from the GA that is signed by Al. Let me see if I can explain the signature and then take a look at your comic again to see if I'm making sense. He writes "A.M" , but the M looks like an "N" with a tiny, unconnected, half-size right line to form the "M". Then he puts a tiny "c" above the "W" (he actually breaks the left line of the W to fit the c in). The "s" at the end is extra long - stylized." Yes that's him. Now I know how to read the signature with the tiny c. Thanks Adam. It's too bad I didn't cover him in that feature then because you're right, that would have made for a long entry. Checking on the GCD, his other credits around that time are FC 378 and FC 400: two Space Cadet issues, both of which are right out of the range I set for the collection (379 to 386). Of course, as per this non-recorded appearance in Crime and Punishment, he might still show up again. As for the Morisi, here are two more pages from that story:

# 36 Crime Can't Win # 9 - Bought from ?? at San Diego last year Content: When the Meuller Gang Struck by Jerry Robinson 7 pgs The Black Pills by Dan Loprino 5 pgs Fingers of Fire by ? 6 pgs The Deadly Clue! by Paul Cooper 5 pgs You know some days I feel like Crime that I Can't Win. Here we have an Atlas book with 3 signed stories out of 4 and two of the artists are complete unknown (or at least, no one bothered to post any information on Dan nor Paul online). Yet, this will not deter me to milk this book for what it's worth on this thread. After all, this is another one that reeks Atom Age / Dark Age / 50s Age / Crime Wave whatever we can't agree to call it. Yes, notice the usual Quality of Production whereby the cover blurb tells us to look in for the M ue ller Gang story when, in fact, we are treated inside to the M eu ller Gang story. But more relevant to the general collecting public, you are looking at a Gerber No Show despite its SI rating of 4. I guess Ernie could find anyone with a copy of this book laden with stories by nobodies about noone. Weird, eh? Seriously, this is reminiscent in my mind to the books that made Ian's last 10 list that include a late issue Buzzy and a late issue Leading Screen, indicating again the scarcity of some of these books (that have low demand and that therefore only few dealers will stock). There is one story to redeem this book as Jerry Robinson opens the book. Jerry received recent extensive and well-deserved coverage in AE 39 and I'd encourage people to refer to this for an in-depth look at his career. For today, we'll cliff-note it via the Comiclopedia entry: "Jerry Robinson was born in New York City. At the age of seventeen, Bob Kane hired him as an art assistant on the newly created 'Batman' strip. In 1941, when Kane moved on to other features, Robinson became the major artist on the strip. But Robinson never received bylines. Together with writer Bill Finger, Jerry Robinson created 'The Joker' (which was the first and also became the greatest villain in comics) and 'Robin, the Boy Wonder' in 1940. Besides working for the 'Batman' strip, Robinson did considerable work for other strips, such as 'Green Hornet' for Harvey from 1942 to 1943, 'Atoman' for Spark in 1944, 'Fighting Yank' and 'Black Terror' (together with Mort Meskin) for Nedor from 1946 to 1949. Robinson worked again with Meskin for National, drawing 'The Vigilante' and 'Johnny Quick' from 1946 to 1949. He drew 'Lassie', 'Bat Masterson', Rocky and Bullwinkle', and 'Nancy Parker' for Western from 1957 to 1963, and also wrote and drew for Timely from 1950 to 1955 and Prize from 1946 to 1949. In 1955 Robinson began working on a science-fiction newspaper strip together with Jet Scott which lasted for four years. Robinson was president of the National Cartoonist Society from 1967 to 1969. He created 'Life with Robinson' in the 1970's. This eventually led to the establishment of the Cartoonist and Writers Syndicate." Looking back over this credit list, it is far more impressive than generally thought of because most every one is quick to point out the Joker relation but he worked on a true Who's Who of comic character: Batman, Green Hornet, Black Terror & Fighting Yank, Vigilante, Lassie, Rocky and Bullwinkle, ... Impressive. Robinson's splash Loprino's splash - The AtlasTales database lists work from Dan mostly from 1951-1954 and one last spurt in 1957-1958 in the pages of Strange Tales. Unknown Cooper's splash - Paul's output as per AtlasTales (which does not claim to be comprehensive yet) is narrower, spanning late 1951 to 1952. P.S.: rjpb - you've got the best eyes of us all - Good catch in the caption. If I get the time, I'll still scan a page with Ma and post it soon. It is still interesting (to me at least) when we can trace the crime story to some element of non-fiction as per this last example. As for Morisi, I can't claim to be an expert as I am more familiar with his later output for 70's Charlton than his early work. Anyone else can shine light on this?

Any chance that is Al(den) McWilliams? If so, you'll have a lot to write about. A rip off of Alvin Karpis? I've read a thing or two make me doubt the accuracy of many of these "true" crime stories. Does you know anyone that's tried to look these up? Anyone? Wow, the thread is alive tonight. 1. When I saw the signature I immediately read it as McWilliams as you did Adam because the name is familiar but reading carefully, this can hardly be read as McWilliams because there is no final s and there is no shadow of the c of Mc. 2. I think you're onto something about Alvin Karpis. His criminal career matches the time period as well as the fact that "He robbed banks, had shoot-outs with the police, kidnapped the wealthy for ransoms, and held up trains. He joined forces with Freddie Barker and his brothers to form the Karpis-Barker gang, known in crime mythology as the Ma Barker Gang. (Ma Barker was not a criminal but merely a devoted mother living with her sons. Only after the old woman was riddled with FBI bullets and killed with Freddie at their home in Florida, did the authorities start the rumour that she was the mastermind of the gang.)" I am going to read over the story because I seem to remember such a character as Ma in it which would clinch the ID. Thanks for the good tip. No having grown up in this country, these are the types of reference that I will miss. 3. Comics on Parade: the indicia carries over many copyright years: 1944-45-48-49-52 probably reflecting the original years of publication of the reprinted strips. Unfortunately, there are no dates on the strips themselves. I am glad you guys liked my scanning selection. I thought that one was the strongest strip in the whole book.

Why wait! Just go to the DC Indices. I already pointed you to the Plastic Man page. It seems that they start around 30 and do continue for a while. I'd say 53 but after a certain point (before 53) they already incorporate a Reds / Spy component alternating with Horror. You did? Sorry about that! Some good eats on that link! No worries POV, bad phrasing on my part. It was meant to mean: I already pointed you to the right section of the website with the URL I provided in my post, not that I directed you to some Plastic Man pages in the past. Glad you enjoyed the link in the end.

Why wait! Just go to the DC Indices. I already pointed you to the Plastic Man page. It seems that they start around 30 and do continue for a while. I'd say 53 but after a certain point (before 53) they already incorporate a Reds / Spy component alternating with Horror.

# 35 Crime and Punishment # 48 - Bought from Tomorrow's Treasures Content: Murder at the Masquerade by A.M.William(?) 7 pgs Henry Darpis - Public Enemy no.1 by ? 8 pgs Caught in a Web by Di Preta 6 pgs Death on Wheels by Fred Guardiner (Sic) 5 pgs And yes as the masthead states, it is "A Thrill a Minute". A few things to note on this. First, it is always nice to look at a Lev Gleason book because the stories tend to be signed so we know who worked on the pages. Second, the cover is not "signed" per se when in general Charlie Biro did the covers but I am guessing that the name of the Band CB was Charlie's way to sign this cover and I have a further hunch that the seating band members could very well be Charlie and Bob (or Lev possibly). I don't have my copy of the recent and excellent coverage of Lev Gleason in CBM to check with the pictures but that's a possibility. I am fairly sure we will see Tony Di Preta again so let me concentrate of Fred Guardineer today. A few bio facts from the Comiclopedia: "Fred Guardineer was born in Albany, New York. After acquiring his fine arts degree in 1935, he went to New York City and drew for several pulp magazines before joining the Harry "A" Chesler shop in 1936. There he drew adventure features for the Chesler books, such as 'Lobo' and 'Dan Hastings', before beginning his freelance comic book career in 1938. Guardineer worked for Centaur (between 1937 and 1939), National (1937 - 1940, working on the 'Zatara', 'Pep Morgan', and 'Speed Sanders' strips and covers), Marvel (1941), Quality (1941 - 1944, working on the 'Tor', 'Merlin', 'Quicksilver', and 'Marksman' strips), Hillman (1946 - 1947), Eastern, Pines, Gleason (1946 - 1953, working mostly on crime stories), and for Me (1952 - 1955, on 'Durango Kid'). Fred Guardineer retired from comics in 1955, at the age of 42, and became a government employee. He moved to San Ramon, California, where he died in 2002." Fred is probably best remembered for his work on Zatara and the covers he did for DC at that time period such as this Action 16 . I'll let others post their copies if they want. Ron Goulart describes Guardineer's art as drawn "in a flat, strongly outlined style and (he) treated each panel as part of the overall design of the page. He favored bright, basic colors. The witches, warlocks, monsters, and madmen he drew for features like Zatara had individuality, and his damsels in distress were pretty and distinctively dressed." AE 10 had an interview with Fred and, more recently, the latest issue of Comic Art Magazine profiles Fred's journal from 1935-1936. Onto all four splash pages: Masquerade story Henry Darpis didn't turn up on any Yahoo! nor Google search Di Preta story Guardineer's race story