-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
-
Posts
1,155 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Everything posted by Blackmask
-
CLOSED -- Joe Sinnott's Personal Atlas Copies
Blackmask replied to Readcomix's topic in Golden/Silver/Bronze Age Only
take -
CLOSED -- Joe Sinnott's Personal Atlas Copies
Blackmask replied to Readcomix's topic in Golden/Silver/Bronze Age Only
Why you, or I, (or anyone) should find it necessary to defend or justify this transaction is utterly nonsensical. The thread was up for days, and multiple people made multiple purchases. The recap post was up for 10 hours before I sent the PM. But honestly, what difference does that even make? If I had seen the thread sooner, my stack may have been even higher! Do I have to ask permission from the lurkers in order to buy a book on a forum for buying/selling books? Or you apologize for selling them? What Bizarro World is this? -
CLOSED -- Joe Sinnott's Personal Atlas Copies
Blackmask replied to Readcomix's topic in Golden/Silver/Bronze Age Only
Per PM, I’m taking the 12 unclaimed books! -
I think my original question is being overlooked….other than the fact that ASM 194, 238, and 252 are on this submission and got 9.8’s (and that we may not agree with the grading on all of them), is there some evidence of impropriety that I’m missing. Is there evidence that it came from the same suspect? Or that it was a reholder submission? I have no connection to ComicLink or the submission, but it seems like there should be some non-circumstantial evidence of impropriety before we call out an auction house for not removing the listing?? I agree that shining light on this issue is in the community’s best interest, but we have to remember that while channeling Hercule Poirot is good….channeling Cotton Mather not so much.