Of course, way back when (SA), it used to go something like this:
First issue of title
Classic cover
Condition
Major event (story)
Renowned artist
Headlights
First appearance in the SA
Really cool splash page or centerfold
Lesser event (story)
Personal taste
Then, it began to change a bit in the BA:
First issue of title
Condition
Renowned artist
Major event (story)
First appearance
Classic cover
Headlights
First appearance in the SA
Really cool splash page or centerfold
Personal taste
I'll let you guys take it from there.