• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

JustJimN

Member
  • Posts

    2,325
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by JustJimN

  1. take Action 508 - 8.5 OW $3Action 483 - 8.0 CROW $3 SSOC 36
  2. take SSOC 36 - 9.2 OW $12MTU 111 - 9.0 OW $2Eerie 106 - 7.5 OW $5SubMariner 70 - 8.0 OW $8Cap America 235 - 8.0 OW $3Defenders 47 - 8.0 CROW $7
  3. take Creepy 25 - 9.6 OW $32Cap America 200 - 9.6 OWW $70
  4. Take Super Villain Team Up 16 - 8.5 OW $10SVTU 17 - 8.0 OW $8 TOD 58
  5. Take Avgs Ann 12 Avgs 192 Invaders 13 Peter Parker 81, 88 FF 197
  6. Take Avgs 151, 177 SSOC 64 Action 491 Marvel 2 in 1 36
  7. MTU 65 - 8.0 OW $44 ghost rider 29 Take
  8. No one can complain about 15 or 16 points. That's only 1 point off the final grades for each comic. I would consider that excellent grading. Send these comics back in a second time for grading and you easily could have 7-8 points.
  9. I also thought the grade was high because of the color scrape across the mid-to-lower front cover.
  10. It shouldn't have with a 3-4 inch spine split. I'm sending all my spin split books in now.
  11. I think the scratch is a scratch. If you take a look at the encapsulated comic, it's still there. It's not just glare. If it was glare in the before picture it shouldn't be in the encapsulated picture. If you look at other encapsulated ASM 300s you won't see this. At least I didn't when I looked at a bunch. Given how uniform the scratch is it may be a production flaw. I don't think I have ever seen this type of scratch. Graders probably haven't either and decided not to take off much for it. Since we can't look at the notes we don't know if this flaw was pointed out. Oh well, on to Round #3.
  12. Mike, if you add up all the people who gave the ASM #300 grades from 4.5 to 7.5 (all considerably less than the 9.2 it got) you have 113 or almost 1/3 of the entrants. There should be some explanation on how this book got such a high grade with a scratch on the spine that breaks color on almost 3/4 of the book. Just asking.