-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
-
Posts
5,497 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Everything posted by Surfing Alien
-
Marvel Comics #1 Voldy slabbed copy on Metro Question
Surfing Alien replied to telerites's topic in Golden Age Comic Books
I don't generally comment over here, but this is fascinating so I'll just say, i'm pretty sure CGC cares about intent, and, since this book was intended to be assembled by the original producer as it sits, they are considering it a book produced by its original producer as it was intended to be. Now whether that should be labeled a proof/ashcan or something else is debatable but they probably don't consider it restored or incomplete if this was an original assemblage by it's producer. -
Thanks. It's funny because I commented on how nice yours was when you recently posted it and then this one popped up. I don't have an alert on it particularly but I look up Popular Librarys a lot and haven't seen a really sharp one for a decent price since I got back into collecting them a couple of years ago. I paid $33 and change for it, which was a steal considering the action this guys auctions were getting and how nice it was. Maybe other bidders looked at it more closely than I did. Just was bummed about that edge hit when it arrived. Anyway, i'll keep both my copies for now, it's a great cover.
-
Whoa, yeah, i'd return that too. I wonder why they thought they could get away with not describing those defects while they never could with a comic book? I think it's one of the inherent difficulties with these " step-children" collectibles - maybe their lack of perceived value and semi-obscurity lead listers to not think or care too much about amateur restoration (or the consequences of non-disclosure). I remember a time in the 70's when it was super common for comic shop owners to hit black cover Marvels with markers all the time, as they were relatively worthless and it made them look new.
-
So I recently won a nice looking paperback on the 'bay and was kind of disappointed to see a hit of black marker on the edge of the cover. I've had a few books with marker hits on them over the years, but usually cheapies that i've found in the wild, not bought online. I'm debating whether I should return it or just chalk it up to the wild wild west nature of paperback collecting, lack of grading and the fact that it was a pittance compared to most comics. It's a tough book to find in nice shape and this was real nice but for the hit. I'm wondering if anyone returns books or pulps they buy that turn out "restored"? I'd think especially pulps, since they are pricier than paperbacks and might tempt evil-doers to hit them with markers etc. ?
-
I'll pound you to a "Pulp" if you don't show off yours!
Surfing Alien replied to mr.schomburg's topic in Pulp Magazines
Ouch!