OK, I just saw this thread.
Phantom Lady 18 is what got me into golden age GGA. It is the first book I bought in this genre- a F/VF copy back in 1995 or so. It is my favorite, but maybe for sentimental reasons. I sold it around 2001 and I regretted it ever since. I have a 3.5 ish copy now and am looking to upgrade.Mine has great color but it has some cover issues. I had a resto copy before that- I kind of wish I would have kept it too.
I 100% agree with Sqeggs about PL 23 being superior. I have had 5 copies of PL 17 over the years and it took me until a few months ago to get my first PL 23. So, for me it is PL 18 in 1st and PL 23 in second. I definitely think 23 is HTF.
Heresy time now ; I hate looking at PL 17- the freaking hands drive me nuts. I am sorry, I know this is the iconic cover, but to me PL 17 is not for me- not that I would turn another one down
Pictures follow of my current 18, 23, and one of my last PL 17.