tomcary106

Just picked up a copy of Batman 244 and considering sending it to CGC to get graded. What would you all grade this copy of Batman 244?

Debating sending this book in to be graded ... could this be a 9.2?

Here's a closer look at the top and the bottom on the back over. You guys still at 7.5? I didn't think it would be a 9.0 as he claimed but I was thinking MAYBE a 8.5 or more realistically a 8.0.

I would say 7.5/8.0 -- nice corners except for bottom left and a few spine rolls. Nice book!

What would you all give this copy of X-men 56? Dealer believes its a 9.0 but I'm a bit concerned about the top. Still learning so any help would be appreciated!

Yes, the small chip on the right middle cover was what I referring to. The staples appear to be in good shape, I've added some more pics to help. Just started learning howto grade so I appreciate the help and feedback! With these new pics, do you think the book could be an 8 or higher?

There is a tiny missing piece on the front cover (middle right) and there is a date stamp on the back of the cover. Besides that, the corners look nice and spine is clean. I'm not sure how much CGC would deduct for these defects. What would you all give this copy?

Thanks for everyone's input, very helpful! You guys are great!

I just picked up this book but am concerned about the top right corner -- it's missing a piece. The previous owner said that it would grade at a 8.0 but I wanted to check in with you all to see what you think. Its a solid book, great gloss, cover is on tight. What would you grade it?

Thanks everyone! I was afraid CGC would knock off quite a bit for the name on the cover but was willing to give it a shot. I'll let you know what it comes back with!

I just purchased this issue of Flash 139 -- its in very good shape except for the obvious flaw of someone writing "Ronnie's" on the cover. I really wanted the issue though so was willing to look past it. What grade do you think CGC would give this book?

wow that is a clean book -- I would give it a 9.0. 8.5 on a bad day

I would give this one a 6.0 -- the top corners look good but the bottom two are not as good, the bend in the bottom left corner takes it down for me. Nice book though!

Hi, I just picked up this copy of X-men 12 and trying to decide if I should send it into CGC. It presents very well, cover is glossy and on tight and there are no missing pages or cutouts. Pages are off white in my opinion. What grade would you all give it?