• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Konrad5288

Member
  • Posts

    60
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Konrad5288

  1. 1 minute ago, Konrad5288 said:

    I was just stating as an example for people to have a general(as stated in my post), not specific, idea of what to look for.  Like on spine. there may be a lot of damage or barely anything but you would know to look at the spine rather than just staring at the book trying to figure it out. There would obviously be more numbers.  If the grader chooses not to make notes why not at least give the submitter a general clue as to why the book was lowered.  And the number 6 "other" was a specific reference to the fact of there being something that the comic was dinged for, but CGC does not want to announce their exact grading criteria to the public. This would probably come into play for only the higher grades.  If you had the "other" listed as reason for a 9.6 instead of 9.8 you could at least cancel out all the other "general" defects. 

    And on anything lower than say a 9.2 why would anyone need the flaws listed? You will be able to see flaws most of the time on a 9.0 or lower comic.

  2. 2 hours ago, Bomber-Bob said:

    This is a fine idea if there were only 5 flaws, like you listed. However, in reality, there are multitudes of flaws, 6 = other just wouldn't cut it. Color fade, stain, thumbprint, substance on book, writing, staple tear, spine roll, indentation, scratch, crease, dirt, chips, dangling chips, waviness, stress, bends, spine split, tape, detached at centerfold, detached on cover, scrape, general wear, pieces missing, etc, etc, etc.  

    I think the only way to get comprehensive notes would be to pay more for the service and perhaps only in certain tiers. Maybe there needs to be a new 'Full Service' tier. This could include, before and after pics, comprehensive notes, extra padding in shipping, etc. Hey CGC, you listening, a Full Service tier option !

    I was just stating as an example for people to have a general(as stated in my post), not specific, idea of what to look for.  Like on spine. there may be a lot of damage or barely anything but you would know to look at the spine rather than just staring at the book trying to figure it out. There would obviously be more numbers.  If the grader chooses not to make notes why not at least give the submitter a general clue as to why the book was lowered.  And the number 6 "other" was a specific reference to the fact of there being something that the comic was dinged for, but CGC does not want to announce their exact grading criteria to the public. This would probably come into play for only the higher grades.  If you had the "other" listed as reason for a 9.6 instead of 9.8 you could at least cancel out all the other "general" defects. 

  3. Definitely 9.4 candidates. Nice corners. The regular has a ding  by the spine, the virgin has a very slight corner crease. Off to the press and hopefully 9.8's

    And then in all of this commotion, i was looking to find some graders and found the third picture. Didnt even know I had it! 2 mini creases like 2mm each near spine perfect corners and barely a bend on one corner. Too bad I sold an NYX 3 a few years back before it got so popular. It would have been a nice addition to these. Will post cgc result on Sanders titles in a month or 2

    1501887439049242629917.jpg

    15018874553841949888787.jpg

    1501887546020-707968999.jpg

  4. On 8/1/2017 at 1:28 AM, bababooey said:

    You're misreading the chart, scroll down to Baltimore to see what an onsite show looks like. 2c

    That sucks!  Oh well..... I received the ungraded set today.  Havent had time to look them over yet, but  will post some pics later.  at first glance they look near perfect.  According to Curtis at Comic Market Street they still had around 13 graded premium sets left last week.   So I ordered one of those too.

    If you were looking for eye appeal you have to get the ungraded though. It's signed in blood red! And matches the Edge of Venomverse title --script. And IMHO is the best looking Edge cover. The preorder was supposed to be signed in gold.  What color will the signatures be on them?  Just have to wait and see.

  5. 1 hour ago, greggy said:

    Good luck getting it onsited at WW Chicago, as CGC isn't doing onsite this year. 

    Also, even if they were, you're a week early on the date. 

    The site said they were doing it when i checked yesterday. Ill check again.  If theyre not at least Ill still get my signed Machete machete and photo op. But, a Hero for Hire grading was supposed to fund all the fun. So all in all that would kind of suck. 

  6. 6 minutes ago, CKinTO said:

    I actually got the same book (though I got the graded 9.8 CGC SS version). Assume you know this, but just confirming - if you bought the signed but ungraded set, and are planning to get it slabbed by CGC, you do know because the signature wasn't witnessed by CGC, you're going to get a green qualified label (and not the yellow sig series label) right? 

    I know. Its for my personal venom collection. With how many copies of the book I ordered plus variants and the Convention in 3 weeks the $55 was almost too much. Why did it have to be an every week run?Hopefully the copy comes nice. Now that I think about it the green label might blend better with the artwork than the yellow one does. 

    Maybe its time to start a new thread here. Refuse CGC SS grading cause it doesnt match the cover like that green qualified one does! lol.

  7. 3 hours ago, gradejunky said:

    these look like character bio sheets from something similar to Marvel Official Handbook???  I remember seeing that same page treatment. Oh yea,  Who's Who of the DC Universe.  Sold as floppies but also apparently like this:

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/Dc-whos-who-in-the-universe-binder-edition-10-13-official-comics-guide-handbook-/131938332962?hash=item1eb8233122:g:NJYAAOSwzaJX2Fcy

     

    Thank you. That just saved me a lot of time. I also have some scattered in a few boxes here and there because i didnt know if they were some kind of print or promotion or what.

  8.  Im just going to go for it and post my results up here for everyone.   I bought that Natali Sanders  Edge of Venomverse premium signed set ungraded from Comic Market Street. Only a total of 150 Virgins signed. Im going to update how it looks when it arrives, and will post the CGC grade here after onsite grading at Chicago Wizard World on the 20th. I might luck out because it looks like the cgc ss are done in gold ink and the regular signatures in a different color.  Thanks for all the responses.

  9. Okay I have looked everywhere and honestly am considering just calling up CGC on this. Someone must know tbe answer though. 

    So anyway my question. I have a near mint/mint Sly Cooper, some really nice Batman Toys R Us reprints, some of the valuable promo comics that are like 4x7 or 5x8 or whatever.  Will CGC grade any of these "promo" books or no? I cant find an answer anywhere on the web.

  10. Ok, so I have a question for anyone here with an opinion or facts on the exclusives/variants that are limited run with a CGC 9.8 guarantee. So lets say a comic will have a total of 500 copies. I can buy the comic "raw" for $30 or CGC graded with 9.8 guarantee for $100. Obviously you get the graded one in 9.8 but what about the raw for $30? Is there any chance for a 9.8 raw or am I just going to get a copy that was rejected by CGC during the 9.8 prescreen?  Any thoughts on this would be appreciated.