-
When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Funnybooks
-
Posts
11,895 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
CGC Journals
Gallery
Events
Store
Everything posted by Funnybooks
-
winning 300 -
On golden age comics, I've seen rusty staples with very minor rust migration grade as high as 8.5 and so I figured this copy was so nice that it was at least 8.0. I changed my mind from submitting an 8.5 to submitting an 8.0 just as I was about to hit Submit Reply.
-
@Funnybooks and @Croatbag, my tie breaker question is the following: What was the original grade of that DD168 book? Happy to privately send William my guess if that's what everyone wants to do...let's wait for @Croatbag to catch up on the thread
-
Not surprising coming from Wolverine!!! I'm willing to suggest the corn on the cob challenge...
-
as @Point Five noted earlier..this was a unique contest in that we had to project the grade after a C&P...from 2 pics with no further information..fun exercise but ultimately not truly a grading contest but more of a speculation contest. It was fun hanging with you guys
-
I think @grendelbo and I may have had the same thoughts on the one book...be curious to hear what you have to say...we usually think along the same lines
-
when we get to the point where we discuss what book tripped us up the most, I think I can explain away the one negative...the other negative....
-
let the group decide? I also feel that @Croatbag was more consistent and happy to concede due to this observation
-
yes...easily the....easiest book to grade...9.4/9.6 leaves very little room for interpretation
