Hello everybody,
I got my Werewolf by Night 32 graded by the other guys and I made the mistake of not getting it pressed first. I was hoping to get a 6.0, but it came back as a 5.0. Before I send it to CGC for a press/regrade, I would really appreciate hearing what you guys think. Do you think it has a chance of moving up to a 6.0 (or a 5.5)? Would CGC grade it any differently than the other guys? I have posted pictures, the grader's notes, and my personal observations. Please let me know what you would do if you were me. Thanks!
It was graded 5.0 with White pages
Grader's Notes:
- Spine stresses and creases break color
- "11-" in logo in pen
- "Small edge and corner creases right front cover breaks color
- Many bends front and back cover
Personal Observations:
- It has a reader's crease that breaks color on the trash can lid and little above it, but not elsewhere
- It has a lot of finger bends on the back cover
- There is an approximately 2.5 inch bend at the top-left of the back cover that also affects many of the interior pages (none of these are color breaking)