• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

RockMyAmadeus

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    54,411

  • Joined

 Content Type 

Everything posted by RockMyAmadeus

  1. RockMyAmadeus
  2. RockMyAmadeus
  3. RockMyAmadeus
    CVA is a service which is of some value to a segment of the slabbed comics buying community.
  4. RockMyAmadeus
  5. RockMyAmadeus
    ?!?!?!?!?!
  6. RockMyAmadeus
    Harris Modern Superior Standard Amalgam Harvey Spire Mirage Charlton Last Gasp Atlas Magazine Enterprises
  7. RockMyAmadeus
    Uniformed bidders are the worst. Thinking they're special because they've got a special outfit...
  8. RockMyAmadeus
  9. RockMyAmadeus
  10. RockMyAmadeus
  11. RockMyAmadeus
  12. RockMyAmadeus
  13. RockMyAmadeus
  14. RockMyAmadeus
  15. RockMyAmadeus
    Where was this? I see no mention of ASM anywhere.
  16. RockMyAmadeus
  17. RockMyAmadeus
  18. RockMyAmadeus
    I appreciate the brevity.
  19. RockMyAmadeus
  20. RockMyAmadeus
    NO one has ever said they will. What people have said OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER ad nauseum in this thread is that the NON-EXISTENT 9.6 and 9.8 copies of Cerebus 1 will - since they don't exist, it may be difficult, but bear with me - sell for a ˆsignificant premium over the corresponding graded Hulk 181s, and that the 5 copies of Cerebus 1 in 9.4 - as shown by GPA data, so this is NOT conjecture - sell for a 50% premium over corresponding graded Hulk 181s.
  21. RockMyAmadeus
    I think you don't know what a Straw man argument is. The topic of this post is questioning if Cerebus 1 is more valuable than Hulk 181. The OP thought that idea wrong... perhaps ridiculous "Really Overstreet?". I presented actual sales that said Cerebus is more valuable than Hulk 181 -in 9.4. And speculated from that data point that the same would hold true in the better than NM grades. If a Cerebus 1 was ever graded 9.8, it too would also sell for much more than Hulk 181 in 9.8. A straw man argument is where one argues against a view the other person DOES NOT HAVE. That is not what I did.
  22. RockMyAmadeus
  23. RockMyAmadeus
    Comparing prices using different grades is the biggest straw man argument in the entire thread. Yeah, that's why this thread was a joke from the start. It was solely based on irrelevant numbers from an annual huge waste of paper. I've never started threads with titles like "It took you a full decade to realize this issue sells for 10x Guide? Really Overstreet?" because I knew it never actually mattered. Um... duh? You of all people should understand how auctions work. It's not like any of your beloved variants have more than 3 (if even that many) people bidding above 50% or so of the hammer in most auctions. Reminds me of certain other (versions of) books that are nowhere near as significant.
  24. RockMyAmadeus
    That can't be true, because they weren't discovered until 1998. "Eminent experts" say so (I must keep things anonymous, so I'm not accused of "cyber bullying", you see, and thrown off the boards yet again.)
  25. RockMyAmadeus
    The West coast didn't see these books until Nov 19/20. DC's official publication date is Nov 17.