• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

AtlasT

Member
  • Posts

    663
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by AtlasT

  1. Here's an illustration of why Canadian reprints are generally held in low esteem. Here's the cover of Reno Browne 51:

     

    Reno51.jpg

     

    ...and here's the Canadian reprint:

     

    CanReno1.jpg

     

    Aside from inferior printing quality, what's the difference? Well, if your eyes aren't too fatigued from reading posts concerning the CGC & J. Ewert Follies, you'll notice that the Canadian book, while claiming to be "a BIG EXTRA VALUE magazine," does not boast "52 GREAT PAGES of WESTERN THRILLS."

     

    This transformation is accomplished by some trimming that makes Jason look like a brain surgeon! While both books boast 5 Reno Browne stories illustrated by the remarkably adroit Russ Heath, the original Reno 51 contains 32 pages of his art, while the Canadian counterpart has only 22 pages worth. Sometimes the pages are simply omitted, and sometimes the ellipsis is accompanied by a nearly legible synopsis:

     

    CanReno3.jpg

    CanReno2.jpg

     

    The inferior printing quality is apparent throughout the book. Still, for all it's shortcomings, it's a pretty neat book, if only as a textbook example of a hack job.

     

    Reno51a.jpg

     

    We now return you to our regularly scheduled .broadcast.

  2. I acquired this book several years ago from Metropolis. I had been searching for a copy of Submariner 32 for several years. The closest I had come was a poor copy, brittle and seriously crumbling in a poly bag, that was offered at the Chicage ComicCon for a non-negotiable $125. This was 1996 or so, and the price was, I'm certain, over GOOD guide.

     

    This Candian copy is numbered 31, and dated 8/49, the month after the date on the domestic Subby 32. The book shows surprisingly bright colors and decent color registration throughout. I apologize for the partial interior scan, but the book is VF or better, and I don't want to stress the spine. Apart from the usual Canadian ads, the book appears to reprint exactly the USA #32.

     

    sm31.jpg

    sm31a.jpg