JennyG13

On 5/12/2023 at 4:40 PM, revat said:

I’d say google a bunch of other similar title comics from the same era

I did, for whatever reason I didn't find the issue. I guess I'll try again.

On 5/15/2023 at 8:31 AM, lostboys said:

Be careful tapping on the slab especially if it has those wedges holding the book in place.

You could tear the the inside of the book away from its staples.

Even if there are no wedges, you could damage a corner.

SCS is real.

OK - that sounds ominous. But noted.

On 5/14/2023 at 9:49 AM, Artboy99 said:

likely it is just the type of spacer they put into the slab. If it really bothers you contact CGC to see if it is a reason for a reholder submission.

Thanks for the feedback. It's hard to know what is standard vs. not acceptable and since I'm new to slabbing I can't foresee how something could be a later issue.

Hi I am new to slabbing. So far my experience with CGC has been less than stellar.  I just received my second batch of comics from a single (first time) order I submitted. I have a Hulk 180 that is slabbed off-center. Can someone please tell me if this is normal for a bronze age, and specifically for a Hulk 180? The other two comics in the order are not off-center, but are both ASM comics. I have no reference point to understand why this comic would be slabbed like this. Any guidance or info is appreciated.

Hey all,

It's been a while, but here is the update, I was slightly surprised, I really didn't think this would grade under 6.0. I had CGC press and clean (no surprises with the interior of book)

It was graded 5.5 - Grader notes: subscription crease back cover

Thanks again for your feedback, I figured folks would like an update.

On 4/23/2023 at 7:38 AM, CGC Mike said:

@JennyG13  There is a 14 day window to return this by submitting a submission form through the mechanical error option.  Be sure to specify the exact problem.  In this case, you would write the hologram affirming authenticity is scratched.  After submitting the form, a prepaid shipping label with automatically be sent to you through our website.  (not by e-mail)  We will fix this and return it to you at our expense.

@CGC Mike thank you for your response and the information. I am presently in communication with customer service.

On 4/23/2023 at 7:38 AM, CGC Mike said:

@JennyG13  There is a 14 day window to return this by submitting a submission form through the mechanical error option.  Be sure to specify the exact problem.  In this case, you would write the hologram affirming authenticity is scratched.  After submitting the form, a prepaid shipping label with automatically be sent to you through our website.  (not by e-mail)  We will fix this and return it to you at our expense.

On 4/22/2023 at 10:00 PM, PovertyRow said:

Well there IS a potential resale problem. Check CGC's own holder description here: CGC Holder Description

The second point states: 
Superior Preservation and Security
The holder’s sturdy outer plastic better resists impacts. The holder design uses precise pressure to lock the comic in place for enhanced protection, and the hologram affirming authenticity is now hot-­stamped and embedded into the plastic for improved protection and increased security.

Note they specify the hologram helps affirm the authenticity (bold/red mine to make it stand out). So some wag may question the authenticity, either before or, god forbid, after the purchase. I hate to take a "buy the sticker" stance but we all know this kind of thing can happen, especially in venues like eBay.

Thank you - this is a view point that I am taking seriously.  I do think you are correct that someone could question this. I have a collection that one day, I will sell. Since, I have never sold a comic, I have zero credibility. This is one of the reasons I opted to get my books graded, because CGC comes with some cred and buyers would know what they are getting from me.  Presently, I am going back and forth with CGC customer service and it's hard to say which way this is going to go. I cannot believe this is my first experience with CGC at present. Fingers crossed. 

I want to sell it eventually, I appreciate this view point. I obviously do not want the book to get damaged if it is handled again, but if it bothers me, I wonder how it may bother a potential buyer.  I have a bad taste in my mouth as this was my very first slabbed book. I've been waiting for years to get my books slabbed. I finally did it and this is what I get back on a walk through. Granted I wouldn't expect anyone to get this back on any book. Sigh

Hi, I had my very first book, a hulk 181 slabbed. It came with a scratched corner and residue where the slab meets. I want to say this should not be something I should accept, because the look of the slab is junked up in my opinion. Since I am not experienced with the ME process, I only just learned about it from posting in the Newbie forum, I'm hoping someone here can help me. I previously submitted a general email to CGC which did not get a response and then I followed up today because it appeared that my contact may not have gone through. Any assistance is appreciated. Photos for reference.

On 4/1/2023 at 7:20 PM, SolidShredder said:

It breaks my heart but 6.0 because of the sub crease. That copy is so nice too. Pressing won't get rid of it either : ( On the bright side, this will be the best looking 6.0 on the market so it'll fetch the high end of the CMV might even sell above it's grade a bit. 

Ugh. I wish it had been a 6.0. It was graded a 5.5 and it came back looking so nice after the clean and press too. 

Hello Everyone,

My very first comic book slabbed, a Hulk 181 and the silver CGC sticker in the corner has arrived with a bad scratch. The side of the slab also have some slight residue (maybe this is normal at the seem). I do not know how normal this is or if I should accept this, as I do not know what will affect the value of this slabbed book. I do find it annoying though. Attaching pictures for reference. Would love to hear the groups feedback. 

It's been a long time - but this was finally graded at a 5.5. Figured folks who took the time to estimate would want to know. Slightly disappointed, but what can you do. I had it pressed and cleaned.

Grader notes: subscription crease back cover breaks color
very light staining all over front cover

Thanks everyone!

On 11/17/2021 at 3:34 PM, Randall Ries said:

If you LOVE the book and want to keep it, you may have the staples either cleaned or replaced and a solvent bath to remove the staining. If you want it graded, you will get a purple label. If you leave it ungraded, you will have a nice looking book for your collection. I would opt for the former in his case. I can handle cover cleaned or even very minor amount of color touch, but not pieces added and tears sealed. A good cleaning and pressing by any means necessary would benefit this book. But keep it raw and the work order with the book so you can tell a future buyer what the deal is with it.

And I would not sell it at a third of its value, either. It's an AMS 129. Cleaned with period staples replaced. I never agreed with a solvent bath considered resto when it s only removing stains and dirt. The book never came with the stains and dirt.

 

So, if I understand correctly - anything beyond dry cleaning is considered restoration? Using a solvent is restoration?  Regardless of how attached I am to some books vs. others... my decision making process comes back to investment and ability to sell the book at some point. In this case blue vs. purple label...do blue books always have higher value/demand?  I appreciate your take and advice on keeping work orders. Still so much to learn...

On 11/17/2021 at 12:58 PM, zzutak said:

Just a standard non-restorative dry cleaning followed by a pressing (both performed by a skilled pro).  Restoration would be a losing proposition.  With the penetrating cover stain, the rusty staples, and other defects that can't be removed, I think you're looking at a "final" grade in the 5.0 VG/FN to 5.5 FN- range.  One man's opinion. 

Thanks, I appreciate this feedback.  I'm still new at all of this, but I'm  wondering if people who have been doing this a long time use CGC to do their pressing and dry cleaning?

Thoughts?  No missing pages and the pictures are in my opinion a good reflection of the book. Appreciate any feedback.

On 11/17/2021 at 11:31 AM, zzutak said:

This looks like a beverage/food stain to me -- perhaps a dribble from an ice cream cone or a thick chocolate shake?  It's penetrated the coated cover stock and is not removable by non-restorative dry cleaning.  Unfortunately, it's regarded as a serious/significant flaw.  

How would you proceed with a flaw like this?  Leave it as is and do a regular press and clean or do some type of restoration?  If it cannot be removed how does this affect the grade?

Thanks in advance for your take  

The pictures are a good representation of the book. No missing pages. It has one rusty staple and I have a photo showing how this appears from the inside of the book as well. I'm wondering how much of an issue this staple is? Thank you in advance for any insight.

Thanks in advance for your take on my copy of ASM 129.  Note that is a stain on the front cover that goes through to the inside cover.  I am unsure of what it is or if it would come off if I had it cleaned (one can hope). No pages missing.

Do any of you think that crease has any chance of coming out with a press? This would be my first experience having a comic pressed and graded.

Thank you in advance for your help/expertise. 

Pictures from my perspective are a fair representation of the book. Thank you in advance for your help/expertise. No missing pages, can easily flip through book. Value stamp present.

Thank you! I think posting the books here to get a sense of the grade is what I will do before I send anything in.  Appreciate the feedback everyone!

Thanks for your insight. I plan to sell.