silversurfer275

you got this for free? nice anyway looking at it its like a 3

back looks good with that photo I would say 5.0 I would press also is that comic spiderman 14?

how much did you pay? and also I would give it 2.5

2 hours ago, RobZe said:

Definitely NFS, just curious how to grade it ... 

im really close to a complete UXM run, never would have happened without dad buying me this ... I want to say he paid 140 in the early 80s.  Seemed like a lot for a rough copy, but it was the only one I ever saw and seems like quite a bargain today!

 thats a huge bargain today wish I got into comics at that time anyway good luck

the pages look alright I would give this a 2 at best at worst 1.0 could be even higher than 2 I doubt it though still a very iconic comic and a great comic to own if I were you I would keep it no way I would sell that if it was a gift from your dad.

not bad like a 5.5 maybe a little overpaid I would not grade it and also wait til he comes in a movie to sell it but it could of been worse good luck with it.

3.5

6 to 7.0 could be wrong could be lower or higher.

4 minutes ago, Mosstastic_22 said:

Ask what exactly? Either way, no I unfortunately don't. Not a big enough collector 

I mean If I was you I would take the chance and grade it and press it but ask around more first to make your choice a press can help it a ton in my eyes

1 minute ago, Mosstastic_22 said:

Thanks all for the feedback. I decided it's best to stay away. I wasn't aware of how much of a liability it could be for pressing books that are otherwise fragile. Guess I'll just wait to try and grab a slabbed one!

do you have anyone you can ask that works for cgc?

1 minute ago, TwoPiece said:

2.5 IMO as is.

I suspect a 3.5/4.0 after press.

you really think its a 2.5? I mean the front cover looks really good and theres some rough spine breaks but I think its better than a 2.5 but thats your option so I really can't argue 

I think a little pressing could help the book looks like a 4.5 luckily for you it does not look bad and its an xmen 1 so that's automatically good. 

15 minutes ago, wiparker824 said:

Thanks! Sorry forgot to get scans before I sent them, only got the photos... no color breaking defects that I could see, bottom left corner is a tad soft. 

yeah at worst 9.6 but its cgc so who knows what it could be let me know if im right about 9.8 though 

9.4 def grade it

5.5 maybe higher

18 minutes ago, wiparker824 said:

based on that photo alone im going 9.8

3 minutes ago, Bird said:

like I said, we never got that far. I don't know, never saw them

oh yeah then pass 

2 minutes ago, Bird said:

never got that far

no like your estimate

2 minutes ago, Bird said:

I don't have any

 

oh whats the grade on those 2?

3 minutes ago, Bird said:

Ask is $900 for this one and WWBN33 & WWBN37. I am passing.

can I see the other 2?

well the people above helped you out but I wanna know what comics do you want to send and who signed them?

lots of rough spine tears but outside of that looks good so 5.5 also how much you paying for that?

really rough but some good stuff that's not so bad but im giving it a 2.0 at best 3.0

do you have any photos?

2 minutes ago, Spider-Guy said:

Would like to keep it being that this could be a high grade. I have really been wanting this book in a higher grade so maybe this is it. Would love to hear some more people chime in on what they think this could grade. 

cool good luck when you send it in I hope you get a high grade