• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

HistoryBuffalo

Member
  • Posts

    125
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by HistoryBuffalo

  1. 6 minutes ago, Qalyar said:

    Any idea if this actually made it into one of the issues of True Comics itself, or if this was just a newspaper strip or the like?

    From what I've read it was a newspaper strip;

    "a contemporaneous account as presented in a January 10, 1943 comic strip where, in a rarity for the times, a Sunday page syndicated to white newspapers featured a Black Man as a hero (and identified as “Negro” in the opening title panel)"

    https://www.dailycartoonist.com/index.php/2021/04/27/navy-may-recognize-black-wwii-sailor/

  2. 5 hours ago, Mecha_Fantastic said:

    Haven't had a chance to read the PDF yet, but were there actually sharks circling them, or were they added to the comic and card for dramatic effect? 

    According to the commendation and story there were indeed sharks nearby in the water. After being interviewed in the 50s French himself commented on there being sharks as well.

  3. 4 hours ago, Robot Man said:

    Congrats Jake. I can tell it went to a real fan. Iconic and the only Timely comic book club. 

    Here is my kit.

    D9C5AE96-F580-4230-A8D0-26DEFAF1F2D2.jpeg

    That kit is sweet! I'm totally going to keep my eye out for a membership card now! I'm definitely enjoying the badge and am even more pleased to have found one without breaking the bank. There are much nicer ones out there such as yours, but for me, this one is perfect! Even if I have an opportunity to upgrade in the future, I'm not sure this badge will leave my collection!

  4. 59 minutes ago, catman76 said:

    There's a thread on this in the golden age section

    Yup, that was my initial thread/post for when I was looking for info, history and leads on these badges. I had another in the want to buy section but have since closed it. This thread was for when I was able to acquire an example of the badge... sort of a celebration post and to share my find with others!

  5. 1 minute ago, KirbyJack said:

    Pretty cool. I’m glad you found one, especially as they apparently fetch way more than I thought!

     The early version of Cap had a distinctive look that the Sentinel badge captures nicely. This is an ad from the March 1941 (same as Cap 1) issue of Marvel Mystery. Note that the mask under the eyes is rounded. 

    273D1795-493E-40CE-8640-AA9ED13E9DBD.thumb.jpeg.df243fc879e1ce04a6e102cfc9bc0170.jpeg
     

     

    That's awesome! I've never seen an ad that early before and I can totally see that the early appearance of Cap is the same as on the badge!

  6. I want to thank everyone of the tremendous help! So it seems that Timely discontinued the badges or rather stopped selling them sometime towards the end of 1943. Perhaps they still had a remaining stock but once those were all sold and gone that was it for the badges.

    I've also seen some differences with the pin mechanism on the back of the badge. It seems the brass badges featured more of a safety pin type backing whereas the later copper pins seemingly featured a hooked back. Not sure if this is correct, however when looking at past auctions and the badges are specifically identified as either brass or copper, each has the different corresponding back. Attached below are examples of the brass and copper backing.

     

    captain-america-sentinel-liberty_1_55f0cd85e55dfbe81aeac29bbb9bda39.jpg

    Screen Shot 2021-05-09 at 4.35.07 PM.png

  7. 1 hour ago, Cat-Man_America said:

    I can't say with specificity, but my suspicion is some time in mid to late 1942. The reason why I'm thinking along those lines is that the switch of badge materials from brass to copper was probably within a short time after we entered the war early in 1942. Since the copper badges are considered rarer than the brass ones, it's logical that they weren't produced for very long.  Note: Copper would also become a war commodity in 1943 when pennies were made out of steel instead of copper...

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1943_steel_cent 

    :tink:

     

    19 minutes ago, pemart1966 said:

    The last reference to joining the club and thus receiving a badge/card that I could find was a house ad in Captain America #20.  It's cover dated November 1942 and had an "on sale" date of September 4, 1942 according to GCD.

    I checked all the way to #30 and found no reference to club membership - neither an invitation to join or an end to the club.

    The highest membership card number that I've been able to find is 72046.  That doesn't tell us anything about dates though.

    Really great information you've both provided. That helps a ton! I always thought the brass badge would have been the more desirable/rare example being that it was produced earlier but I guess having a lower quantity compared to that of the brass badge will do it to. Everyone wants to have the more limited edition or example! Issue #20 is still pretty early in Cap's publication history, so it's neat that the badge goes that far back. Again, really awesome info. I appreciate it tremendously!

    Jake

  8. Out of curiosity, does anyone know when production of these badges was halted in order to conserve materials for the war effort? I've heard 1942 and1943 but haven't found anything definitive. I'm also curious in figuring out a potential number of badges produced. There isn't a ton of information on these despite the history surrounding them and I think it makes them all the more fascinating! I may have to take a deeper dive into finding out more now that the spring semester is over. A summer research project perhaps as a break from my regular studies!

  9. Hi all,

    I found a different copy of the Security Measures movie tie-in for a better price. Condition actually seems pretty good save for the bottom rear left edge. I've been told the lighter colored marks are ink transfers? Anyway, I'm curious as to some more opinions on this copy! Being that these issues are hard to find as it is, I'd be pleased with a 9.2 at the very least. I'm also thinking a quick press might help but am unsure as to the effect it could have on a modern book such as this, with a seemingly thicker cover and being of an unconventional size. Thanks so much!

    Jake

    s-l1600.jpg

    s-l1600-1.jpg

    s-l1600-2.jpg

    s-l1600-3.jpg

    s-l1600-4.jpg

    s-l1600-5.jpg

  10. Hi all,

    I'd like some opinions as to what this might grade? It's a got a pretty beat up cover with classic Marvel chipping on all edges but the biggest flaw is the missing chunks near the staples and spine. I've always liked this issue and may pick it up regardless as it is a semi-key with the first appearances of Pepper and Happy, plus it is a lot cheaper than other copies I've seen at $50 bucks and the page quality looks good!

    Any and all opinions welcomed!

    Jake

    0.jpeg

    0-1.jpeg

  11. Hi all,

    Just wanted to share the final price of this auction I'd been watching. With shipping the final hammer price on this copy of Cap #54 was $633.99!! I know that it has a Schomburg cover but geez! I'm shocked but in this market I really shouldn't be...

    https://www.ebay.com/itm/265132995188?autorefresh=true&nma=true&si=HKFkqM1A7g0wB%2Fwl9Fyuu5g%2FvM8%3D&orig_cvip=true&nordt=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557

    Jake

  12. Hi all,

    I came across some insert cards created by Rittenhouse in collaboration with Marvel from 2015. They are called "archive cuts" and each card contains an actual panel cut from an original golden, silver or bronze age issue. Most of the issues aren't major keys... for example Cap #34, #35 and #44 but neat comics nonetheless, however I did notice there are panels from Avengers #1 and Avengers #4. In fact I think there was a separate set that featured panels from each issue from #1-#100. I feel a lot of collectors would frown upon this as any comic has historical and monetary value to a degree, especially key issues and these are being pieced out. What do you all think? I'm curious!

    Attached below are some sweet Cap panels

    Thanks,

    Jake

    s-l500-3.jpg

    s-l500.jpg

     

     

    s-l500-1.jpg

  13. Hi all,

    Looking for some opinions as to what this Iron Man Security Measures, DVD exclusive comic may possibly grade. The comic isn't in hand so these scans are all I've got. For modern comics I know that 9.6-9.8 is the standard when grading and would like some opinions as to whether or not that would be attainable with this issue.

    Thanks!

    Jake

    s-l1600.jpg

    s-l1600-1.jpg