@rexinnih
@956Ref
The attached examples have Best Wishes. The JSA approved is from Roz, in my opinion. The other three are from the King in person.
In my opinion, the To Paul piece is a Roz proxy signature. Even without looking at the Kirby signature and just looking at the letter W in wishes you can see that both the JSA and Paul pieces have a hook on the W. The rest do not.
Looking at the relationship between the height and transition of the letter b and y in Kirby, one can see that that Paul piece is also more similar to the JSA piece. There are other problems with the small K and big K that I dont want to go into detail because it could help forgers.
Look at the angle of the B in Best. Compare that to the angle of J and K in each the examples. In the true signatures they are same angle as J and K. In the Paul and JSA piece, they are not. So the forger only focused on making the angle of J and K the same, but forgot to make the angle of the rest of the To Paul and Best, the same angle as the J and K. In many cases with dedications added, its easier to spot fakes.
Therefore there are several inconsistencies that suggest it is a proxy.