Another GL for the road. Please grade my Green Lantern #66!

[Point Five]

Front looks super nice and glossy, but a few minor flaws on the back. The upper left corner of the BC has a small "hanging chad", as do the pages. (Is there a chance this is a printing/cutting flaw?) There's also a very subtle watermark at the bottom edge of the BC, just barely visible. Your grades & comments welcome. Thanks guys!

 

 

[gernblanston]

5.5

[Shadow]

I went 7.5. I can't see how this is anywhere near a 5.5. I don't think the "stain" would weight it down because it's virtually invisible.

 

Nice looking book!

[Mr.Diggler]

7.0, couple of dings here and there.........I agree the stain is tough to see.........nice book

[CAP Freak]

6.5 Nice to see not much has changed in 3700 years...

[JohnT]

I went for 7.0.

 

As far as the hanging chad, I assume that is a production byproduct. I have otherwise solid books that have it, or the corners missing from most or all of the pages. Can't see it being from anything other than a dull blade during trimming (or however comics are cut in production).

 

I'm sure someone out there knows!

[marvelcollector]

I went with 7.5..Nice copy (thumbs u

[bronzilla]

7.5 BC brings it down still sweet book (thumbs u

[bronzilla]

[Calamerica]

6.0

[arexcrooke]

One of my favorite GL's

Nice book

 

[Point Five]

Thanks!

 

So with only 17 votes cast, every grade from 5.5 (!) to 9.0 (!!) got chosen. Tough book to grade I guess!

[divad]

Thanks!

 

So with only 17 votes cast, every grade from 5.5 (!) to 9.0 (!!) got chosen. Tough book to grade I guess!

 

Not really . . . 7.0 without water stain and rippling along REBC . . . consequently a very nice 6.5

[Point Five]

I'm cool with the grade, but there's no rippling along the back cover edge. From the BC scan I can see why you'd think so tho.

 

 

[Mr. Zipper]

I voted 7.0, but I think 7.5 is a strong possibility.

 

TTBOMK, the "hanging chad" or corner tag is from the cutting process and would be counted as a production flaw. When it goes into the internal pages, that signals to me that it was most likely the result of the original trimming process.

[Point Five]

TTBOMK, the "hanging chad"

Didn't he fight ZZUTAK in one of the early Strange Tales?