Post your most recent Modern submission success/failure here

[Comicdey]

Post your most recent Modern CGC submission success or misery stories here

 

Thought I knew how to grade....at least they all have White pages.

 

Not totally unhappy, but I don't know what it takes to get the 9.8 grade for the baxter type 1980's Watchmen books. These 9.6's are perfect, no prints, no flaws...nuttin? I'm lost with those, so will need to call for graders notes.

 

Should be arriving in Alaska in the next month or so depending on how CGC packages up multiple submissions....the SA group that I sent still hasn't been verified.

 

Nailed 3 grades

Undergraded 3 grades

Overgraded 4 grades

 

Back to school for me...or maybe a few more minutes looking at them in the process.

 

Watchmen issues

 

3 9.6+ (CGC 9.6) Nailed it

4 9.8 (CGC 9.6) Overgraded 1 step

5 9.8 (CGC9.6) Overgraded 1 step

6 9.6 (CGC 9.4) Overgraded 1 step

11 9.6 (CGC 9.6) Nailed it

12 9.6+ (CGC 9.8) Undergraded 1 step

 

X-men issues

 

137 9.6 (CGC 9.8) Undergraded 1 step

212 9.6 (CGC 9.4) Overgraded 1 step

216 9.8 (CGC 9.8) Nailed it

266 9.6+ (CGC 9.8) Undergraded 1 step

[gernblanston]

X-Files 1 1/95 Topps Comics Modern 9.8 My grade: 9.6

Vampirella 1 11/92 Harris Modern 9.2 My grade: 9.6

Preacher 1 4/95 D.C./Vertigo Comics Modern 9.0 My grade: 9.2

Preacher 1 4/95 D.C./Vertigo Comics Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.8

Preacher 1 4/95 D.C./Vertigo Comics Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.4

Preacher 1 4/95 D.C./Vertigo Comics Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.4

Saga of the Swamp Thing 20 1/84 D.C. Comics Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.4

Watchmen 3 11/86 D.C. Comics Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.6

Watchmen 4 12/86 D.C. Comics Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.6

Watchmen 7 3/87 D.C. Comics Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.6

Watchmen 10 7/87 D.C. Comics Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.6

Watchmen 11 8/87 D.C. Comics Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.6

G.I. Joe A Real American Hero 1 Modern 9.8 My grade: 9.6

G.I. Joe A Real American Hero 1 Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.6

Cry For Dawn 5 Spring 1991 Second Printing Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.6

300 1 5/98 Dark Horse Comics Modern 9.6 My grade: 9.8

300 2 6/98 Dark Horse Comics Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.8

300 3 7/98 Dark Horse Comics Modern 9.8 My grade: 9.8.

300 4 8/98 Dark Horse Comics Modern 9.8 My grade: 9.8

300 5 9/98 Dark Horse Comics Modern 9.8 My grade: 9.8

Grendel 1 3/83 Comico Modern 9.4 My grade: 9.4

NYX 3 2/04 Marvel Comics Modern 9.8 My grade: 9.8

Cry For Dawn 1 4/89 CFD Publications Modern 9.0 WHITE My grade: 9.2

 

 

It looks like 8 overgrades, 13 on the nose, and 2 undergrades. I still cannot believe the overgrade on 300 #1 and 2--they both are flawless and all 5 are in the same condition, with the others getting the 9.8.

 

[Comicdey]

no others want to admit their past cgc transgressions or success stories?

[divad]

no others want to admit their past cgc transgressions or success stories?

 

It's kind of a Gabriel's story (come blow your horn) . . . it means much more when it looks like this:

 

Just wanted to say thanks! I sent the IM annual #5 NM+ I bought from you awhile ago and it graded a 9.8

 

A true story . . . of many

 

 

[Comicdey]

I've had that happen many of times with books I've sold as Raw....Hulk 181 7.5 CGC 8.5.....for example......I just wanted to see what types of books are being graded, and how people are doing with it.

 

Curiosity....