Giant sized X-men 1

[senbi575-migration]

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

[CAP Freak]

6.5

[silverage12c]

I dunno . . . being printed sideways like that is one helluva defect. Can't go higher than a 2.0 because of that.

 

But, seriously, I'd like to see a scan (vertical or not) that isn't cropped so close to the spine. Assuming the spine is pretty clean, there's also less damage around the staples than youoften see with these square-bounds. But, I see big diagonal creases at both top corners, so I agree with Cap's 6.5. Nicer than my 4.0/4.5 copy, though!

[comic_lot]

Based on front cover, 6.5/7.0, based on bend in URC and possible blunting on other corners and chip (?) in LLC.

[senbi575-migration]

I thought the corners would really affect the grade here is a better pic.

 

[CAP Freak]

Wow. I thought that was a bad guess.

[Aces]

6.5-

[gernblanston]

6.0/6.5

[TFL-migration]

I have a CGC 6.5 of this book. Not even close.. I will say 5.5

[Count]

5.5 - 6.0