PGM: Tales to Astonish #8

[cheetah]

Very small chip on RFC next to the word 'comics' in the CCA stamp. Some minor stressing along TFC and TBC.

 

 

[Calamerica]

Very tough comci to get in this grade.

 

Yes this IS a high-grade comic - not mid-grade...

 

Gotta go w/ VF 8.0.

 

Possible VF+ 8.5.

 

CAL

[Shark]

Beautiful issue. I'd say VF+.

[JohnT]

Mummex...

 

I'll have to say 8.0 on this one. Looks like a few spine stresses in addition to the top cover issues.

[djpinkpanther67]

VF to VF+

[cheetah]

I think this is one that CGC won't grade due to overhang on the top cover. I'm guessing up to one out of three in the TOS and TTA runs will get rejected. Anyone know how much of an overhang CGC can handle before the won't grade?

[gernblanston]

I would go 8.5.

On the overhang issue, I have had them reject some books on that basis in the past, but I sent them in again 2 years later and they were graded. :shrug:

[Aces]

8.5+