PGM SANDMAN #4 from NYC show

[WEBHEAD]

This one was sold as poor ( timmed? ) it's got a nicer cover then my graded 3.0

The top looks like it might have trimmed or it might just be a printer defect.

Ideas??

 

 

 

book is complete no tears or rips on the inside...

 

personaly I think it was a sweet deal

 

WEBHEAD

[CAP Freak]

I agree 3.0

[JohnT]

That's the worst trim job I've ever seen! And yes, it's definitely trimmed. If I were you I'd trim it again so it is straight, and then you'll have a decent looking trimmed book. If you got it for a Poor price, then that's great.

[TheAvenger80]

Yeah that trim job didn't work out the way somewhat wanted. I can almost see the look on ther face. haha. Nice book in any condition tho. 2.5?

[gernblanston]

2.5

[rjpb]

That's the worst trim job I've ever seen! And yes, it's definitely trimmed. If I were you I'd trim it again so it is straight, and then you'll have a decent looking trimmed book. If you got it for a Poor price, then that's great.

 

I'd probably call it a FR - Poor I reserve for books that are literally falling apart, too brittle to read, have chunks out of the whole book, rendering the story unreadable, or otherwise seriously incomplete.

 

What do people consider "a Poor price" - 20% of good?

[nik]

Thats more like butchered then trimmed

[djpinkpanther67]

looks like the blade was dull on the exacto knife

[joeypost]

looks like the blade was dull on the exacto knife

 

The only thing dull in that equation was the person holding the knife. I agree that a second trimming is in order.

[thehumantorch]

Looks like they tryed to trim it with a weed whacker. Don't think I could ever retrim a book.