Justice League of America 200

[nocutename]

Just got an order of comics in and am not pleased with them. I am not a great grader but can detect flaws. Tell me what you think and I will post what the seller graded them at.

 

BTW - I am new here - Should I only post one comic per thread?

 

 

 

 

Thanks for looking and grading.

[Bomber-Bob]

I'm sorry to say I would only grade it as VG.

[TFL-migration]

Welcome to the boards!! First a maximum of 2 book's per PGM book should be practiced. It's easier on everyone. As far as the book goes... I would say it is a 4.5 IMHO. Though I could see a few people grading it @ 5.0 It present's better than the technical grade. Again, IMHO... Is the spine split/torn on the BC LRC?? Look's like it might be from the scan's. Very hard to tell actually...

[Old Fashion PB and J]

I am saying VG/F. But am giving the benefit of the doubt. If the spine does have a split, and there is probably something I am not seeing also then 4.0

[nocutename]

Spine is not split but there is a small tear lower corner. Top corner spine is not looking to great either. PQ - very brownish in my opinion as well.

 

I would agree that this looks like a fine. The seller graded it as a VF. Very disappointed in this shipment. I have a few others I'll post separate.

[nocutename]

Welcome to the boards!! First a maximum of 2 book's per PGM book should be practiced. It's easier on everyone. As far as the book goes... I would say it is a 4.5 IMHO. Though I could see a few people grading it @ 5.0 It present's better than the technical grade. Again, IMHO... Is the spine split/torn on the BC LRC?? Look's like it might be from the scan's. Very hard to tell actually...

 

I not hip on all the lingo, so what's a PGM

[Old Fashion PB and J]

PGM= Please Grade My

[oakman29]

4.5

[nocutename]

PGM= Please Grade My

 

Thanks

[MagnetoWasRight]

4.0-4.5

[nocutename]

Thanks everyone for grading this comic.