Showcase 84

[nocutename]

Let me know what you think about this one. I think that these were graded correctly but I am not sure

 

 

[oakman29]

7.5/8.0 due to spine stress,and LRC ding (thumbs u

[MagnetoWasRight]

7.5

[nocutename]

Thanks for grading this comic. The seller listed all the Showcases as a fine and they look good to me. I just wanted to check to see if these matched the grade.

 

I can't wait to read this story!

[TFL-migration]

Those BC "lines" worry me a bit. Do you think they are production related? Look's like they may very well be. For purposes of grading. I will call them production "faults"..

7.5 IMHO. If those marks on the BC are not production related. I would deduct 1 - 1.5 off of the book. Again, IMHO Nice book BTW..

[nocutename]

Those BC "lines" worry me a bit. Do you think they are production related? Look's like they may very well be. For purposes of grading. I will call them production "faults"..

7.5 IMHO. If those marks on the BC are not production related. I would deduct 1 - 1.5 off of the book. Again, IMHO Nice book BTW..

 

Thanks. They do look like production lines especially looking at the inside back cover where there are words. But I did notice a slight tear in the back cover less than 1/4 inch at the bottom. Its difficult to see from the scan, but its aligns with the kid with the green pant's knees. But I think that a small tear is allowable in a fine, no? I'll have to check the grading again but it doesn't bother me. This is a good learning experience.