G.I. Joe 21

[TFL-migration]

Your grades and opinions are once more appreciated. Pages are White. Thanks. The top staple on the BC is perfect. Just got hit a bit with the black stripe ink. Sorry for the slightly small scans. I'm still learning the new re size program.

 

I got this book off of a Canadian Ebay seller. He had it graded as a 8.5. He said he knew it was better. But he didn't want any un happy customers/negs. I was very happy/shocked when I got the book.

[oakman29]

9.4 (thumbs u

[The Silver-Age]

9.0-9.2

[Earl Davis]

Well it's better than an 8.5.

 

I would be tempted to say 9.0 if I was grading it for myself because of the ink with the staple, but it's a more unusual defect so I am not sure what the general opinion is.

[madzlin]

My copy that I purchased as a teen for cover price just got graded as a 9.8.

 

I've followed some of the recent eBay auctions for this issue and it seems that CGC can be pretty strict. I think this strict grading is the norm for CGC when it comes to Bronze age or newer books.

 

With this in mind, I think your book is a 9.0/9.2.