Grading Impact of Page Detached from Staple

[Bomber-Bob]

Check out the following pic, a blue label with a detached centerfold.

They will give a GLOD or Blue depending on which they feel is best for you.

BTW, Eric is a good guy but not a grader. However, he is always willing to chat with you and answer all questions as best he can = very helpfull and knowledgable.

[divad]

Check out the following pic, a blue label with a detached centerfold.

 

This is a good development.

 

 

They will give a GLOD or Blue depending on which they feel is best for you.

 

Emphasis on they

 

 

BTW, Eric is a good guy but not a grader. However, he is always willing to chat with you and answer all questions as best he can = very helpful and knowledgable.

 

Eric's job is to make the irate caller "feel better" . . .

[comicdiablo-migration]

For the moment at least, I joined this board because I noticed some folks debating back and forth about if comics with a centerfold detached at one staple would only receive green labels or sometimes blue labels. Currently, I am forming a collection of collection of Amazing Adventures, which was the first comic series I was exposed to in childhood, and I noticed this listing on eBay:

 

Amazing Adventures 7 CGC 9.6

 

Look at the supersized image and notice that it clearly states on a BLUE label, "Centerfold detached from one staple only."

 

This is a HUGE discrepancy in CGC and Overstreet grading standards, which shocked me at first. So I googled and found this thread discussing the topic, among others, and wanted to provide additional evidence that it is not always a green label given by CGC to a comic with a centerfold detached at one staple.

[Junkdrawer]

Check out the following pic, a blue label with a detached centerfold.

They will give a GLOD or Blue depending on which they feel is best for you.

BTW, Eric is a good guy but not a grader. However, he is always willing to chat with you and answer all questions as best he can = very helpfull and knowledgable.

From only what I can see in this photo, it appears a very well preserved book. Perhaps it was pummeled down to a 6.0. Doesn't look like a 6.0 from what I see.