how bout a SURVIVOR SERIES for EC Comics??

[Aman619]

there are a lot of great covers, and I dont think we've ever tried to narrow down the very best....

[Subliminal]

Sounds like a good idea (thumbs u

[PokerKid]

Do you do categories (Sci-Fi, horror, everything else) or just let T-rex battle decapations and priates?

[Aman619]

good question. there are genre trends.... but why not just throw up every EC comicbook and see what sticks around til the end. There are some awesome covers.

[Cimm]

good question. there are genre trends.... but why not just throw up every EC comicbook and see what sticks around til the end. There are some awesome covers.

 

 

Case in point...

[Green]

sweet camel toe

[TheWatcher]

My prediction is that either Weird Science-Fantasy 29 or Crime Suspenstories 22 would win

[Cimm]

Y'know... I gotta say, even though I am a huge Frazetta fan, I've never really gotten excited at the cover for WSF 29... not sure why, it just doesn't do anything special for me... I like the cover for Weird Science 22 the best from the EC sci-fi...

[TheWatcher]

I like the cover a lot, but I like CSS 22 more. However, I believe the masses would vote Frazetta top dog

[Scrooge]

I like the cover a lot, but I like CSS 22 more. However, I believe the masses would vote Frazetta top dog

 

Isn't that why you shouldn't let the masses vote?

 

Yup, I predict that would be the winning cover ... but you never know. It'd still be interesting to see the Top 5 make up. (thumbs u

[Aman619]

lots of great Davis covers....

[Doctor Svord]

I like the cover a lot, but I like CSS 22 more. However, I believe the masses would vote Frazetta top dog

 

Isn't that why you shouldn't let the masses vote?

 

Yup, I predict that would be the winning cover ... but you never know. It'd still be interesting to see the Top 5 make up. (thumbs u

 

The Bulls-Eyed, Caveman, Pin Wheel cover? Not Frazetta's best effort. If people are fans of the Raymond style, the Williamson T-Rex cover, IMHO, is far superior.

 

Another vote for: Yes, that's a great idea for a survivor series.

 

 

[goldust40]

I'm all for an E.C. survivor series. With so many classic covers it should be engaging stuff.

[Jeffro.]

Here's my nomination

[goldust40]

Here's my nomination

 

The guy only wanted a slice of shortcake.

[Subliminal]

I think it would be better if they were split into four categories and then each round runs four polls at once and when they are down to one book for each category the final poll is between the four top books

 

 

[short_box-migration]

My prediction is that either Weird Science-Fantasy 29 or Crime Suspenstories 22 would win

 

I'm putting in my vote for either Vault of Horror # 30 and Shock Suspenstories # 9 right now then!

[short_box-migration]

good question. there are genre trends.... but why not just throw up every EC comicbook and see what sticks around til the end. There are some awesome covers.

 

 

Case in point...

 

That cover shouldn't even make the Top 20. There are sooo many better than that one.

[Mutant Manatee]

My prediction is that either Weird Science-Fantasy 29 or Crime Suspenstories 22 would win

 

I'm putting in my vote for either Vault of Horror # 30 and Shock Suspenstories # 9 right now then!

 

 

Now's your chance to show off your complete collection of Tiny Tots!

[Mutant Manatee]

Soooooo many to choose from! Wally Wood! Al Feldstein! Johnny Craig! Jack Davis! Al Williamson! Frank Frazetta! And can't forget "Ghastly" Graham Ingels...