Check my grade for Silver Surfer #14

[badshot-migration]

Okay, I've submitted several books for grading here hoping to get an idea as to how you all grade books. I've watch the other post and I am giving you my first attempt at grading one of my books. You can let me know what you think.

Here's the book:

 

Okay, If I was only grading on the cover alone I'd give this book a 9.2 but because of the back cover I am giving it an 8.5.

 

How'd I do?

 

[porcupine48]

7.5 IMHO.

[oakman29]

with the spine,and lower left corner.I would say 6.5/7.0 (thumbs u

Welcome to the boards too!

[badshot-migration]

with the spine,and lower left corner.I would say 6.5/7.0 (thumbs u

Welcome to the boards too!

Thanks for the welcome. Apparently I still have a lot to learn as my grade was way off.

 

[thehumantorch]

7.5

 

Spiderman against the Surfer, great issue. Welcome to the boards

[tortoise]

6.5 imo, that corner is just to ruff

[ARK]

6.5/7.0

[dopy02]

Welcome to the boards

nice big scans > well done

if only there was some procedure available to improve that corner

[mystrymachine]

7.5

[JohnT]

7.0.

 

Somebody should invent a procedure...

[etanick]

7.5/8.0

 

that front with the color breaking ticks, the blunt lower corner, and the color loss scuff are too much to be a 9.2 that think it is...the front I think is actually worse than the back in my opinion.

 

my grade is 7.5 for the front and 8.5 for the back.

[zuckuss2003]

7.5 the LLC is rough but I don't think it is all that bad.

[The Silver-Age]

7.5

[MagnetoWasRight]

7.5

(thumbs u

[Comicdey]

bump kills you.....7.0-7.5

[TFL-migration]

7.0 Possible 7.5 In Hand. IMHO WTTB

[ROBTOTHEC]

7.0 Possible 7.5 In Hand. IMHO WTTB

 

I AGREE!