PGM ASM 38

[Howard The Duck]

Probably first and last old comic I'll ever buy but here goes:

 

 

 

[tortoise]

cropped to close for an accurate grade

[Howard The Duck]

Rescanned and updated. Thanks.

[tortoise]

rounded corners, overall tanning brings it down

F- imo (5.5)

[etanick]

6.0

[trmoore54]

Is that double-dot BC top left a stain? I'm good on 5.5...

Why the first and only?

[Howard The Duck]

Had it graded at C2E2 and sending it in for pressing and slabbing by Classics Incorporated. And their answer is

7.5-

[tortoise]

Had it graded at C2E2 and sending it in for pressing and slabbing by Classics Incorporated. And their answer is

7.5-

 

i really dont see how that gets anywhere near 7.5

[Calidream'n]

Had it graded at C2E2 and sending it in for pressing and slabbing by Classics Incorporated. And their answer is

7.5-

 

i really dont see how that gets anywhere near 7.5

Maybe there's hope for my "reader" copies after all!

[Howard The Duck]

I, too, am kind of skeptical on some of the pre-press grades I got. But the proof is in the pudding. When I get it back from CGC we'll see how accurate the grading actually is.

[oakman29]

7.5 are you kidding? 5.5/6.0 tops

[Howard The Duck]

Well, he did qualify it with a - so it is a 7.5 minus if I wasn't clear.

[tortoise]

Well, he did qualify it with a - so it is a 7.5 minus if I wasn't clear.

so... a 7.5 is a VF -, so is he calling it a VF --

 

i stand behind my 5.5 grade F-

[Howard The Duck]

Years later, or so it seems, I just got my ASM back. CGC 7.5 Off-White pages. Soon to be for sale!

[chrisware]

Congrats, Duckman.

 

No offense, but if CGC graded that a 7.5 then they need to get Steve Borock back in a big hurry.

 

I agree with the other posters--a 6.0 at best.

[oakman29]

Congrats, Duckman.

 

No offense, but if CGC graded that a 7.5 then they need to get Steve Borock back in a big hurry.

 

I agree with the other posters--a 6.0 at best.

 

Congrats on the grade.

[Howard The Duck]

Tada!!