Please grade this FF 17

[JohnT]

7.5 because the crease looks like it breaks color. Otherwise beautiful!

[thehumantorch]

8.5-9.0 stunning book (thumbs u

 

No offense, but you either need to get a copy of the OSGG and read it front to back, or invest in a new monitor . . .

 

well I did just wake up

but other then the crease in the urc i dont see any flaws

i hve no problem with u criticizing my grading, but if u are going to criticize it, you should post a grade to.

 

Would agree with 7.0.

 

Dust shadow on right front edge hurts the grade.

[Bomber-Bob]

It depends on how bad the foxing on the front cover is in hand. The upper right corner crease probably makes it an 8.5. The foxing brings it down to a 7.5. Depending on freshness and page quality maybe less. 7.0 - 7.5 range.

[divad]

It depends on how bad the foxing on the front cover is in hand. The upper right corner crease probably makes it an 8.5. The foxing brings it down to a 7.5. Depending on freshness and page quality maybe less. 7.0 - 7.5 range.

 

You mean shadowing, oxidation or tanning . . . I don't see any "foxing" anywhere on the book.

[Bomber-Bob]

It depends on how bad the foxing on the front cover is in hand. The upper right corner crease probably makes it an 8.5. The foxing brings it down to a 7.5. Depending on freshness and page quality maybe less. 7.0 - 7.5 range.

 

You mean shadowing, oxidation or tanning . . . I don't see any "foxing" anywhere on the book.

 

Yes, that is what I mean. I seem to use foxing as a generic term for any of the above. To me the end result is the same whether it was caused light, dust, paper acids, etc. and I guess I like to say foxing.

[tortoise]

8.5-9.0 stunning book (thumbs u

 

No offense, but you either need to get a copy of the OSGG and read it front to back, or invest in a new monitor . . .

 

well I did just wake up

but other then the crease in the urc i dont see any flaws

i hve no problem with u criticizing my grading, but if u are going to criticize it, you should post a grade to.

 

Yeah David!

 

I agree with everyone ELSE!

 

hey I can take it, I was wrong on this one.

but if youre gonna call someone out, at least share ur opinion before 10 others do

 

[jimjum12]

Nice clean edges, very little spine wear, relatively flat except for URC crease/fold....and deep colors that suggest good gloss that most scanners are horrible at capturing.....it looks like a classic 7.5 to me. GOD BLESS...

 

-jimbo(a friend of jesus) (thumbs u

[jerster]

I vote 7.0.

[loboagain]

7.0/7.5 nice looking copy.

[etanick]

7.0 easy for me and I wouldn't be shock to see a higher grade.