Gothic Romances 1-S

[taylorj-migration]

 

I finally joined CGC and was thinking of submitting THREE magazines to get a feel of the system. Would anyone care to guesstimate the grade on this magazine? I am submitting:

 

1) Gothic Romances 1-Shot

2) Gothic Tales of Love #3

3) Nightmare #2 - from a set of TEN mags I bought in which they all are of the same quality. They are Nightmare 1-5 and Psycho 1-5.

 

Anyway, here is one of the three, Gothic Romances, that I am sending in so please provide feedback!

 

This book does have a small chip/paper loss on the back left side midway ...Sure wish that was not there.

 

 

[bounty_coder]

Beatiful copy, perhaps one of the nicest you will find. But I think that crescent crease on the front cover brings it down to a VF+ 8.5...

[bill999]

The defect seen on the back cover by the womans left ear would make the magazine grade in a CGC 7.5 I feel.

[bounty_coder]

The defect seen on the back cover by the womans left ear would make the magazine grade in a CGC 7.5 I feel.

 

You know what, I completely missed that. Is that a chunk of rear cover missing near her ear? If so this would probably bump down to a 6.0 FN at best...

[Subliminal]

Personally I would bump it down just for the eye shadow she is wearing

 

Hopefully Talorj will return before the mayflies do and tell us more about this book