PGM: GA Flash #46

[Jaymole]

Hi All

 

Not sure if I will be selling this or not, but just in case, I was wondering what grade would you give this. It's in really beautiful condition (snow white pages) except it has 1 1/2 inch tear on the lower back cover.

 

Thanks in advance for any help!

 

 

 

 

[Comicdey]

That is a beauty, miscut in all it's glory. Wouldn't have noticed the tear if you hadn't mentioned it.

 

I don't see a crease, a corner ding, or a blemish...but then again, I'm not looking that hard....Without the tear, 9.4/9.6 even? With the 1.5" tear....8.0-8.5?

 

that's tough...I'm sure I'd be losing if this one was in a grading game...

 

 

[TFL-migration]

8.0 IMHO. It's shame such a nice book has that tear. Without the tear this book would be a solid 9.2 IMHO. Still a very nice book without question. What is the page quality like? It look's like it would have a legitimate shot at white pages!?

[Stevenrams]

8.0 perhaps 8.5. Does CGC downgrade for miscut books? I'm not sure. In any case it's a beautiful copy. What is your asking price?

[Jaymole]

8.0 IMHO. It's shame such a nice book has that tear. Without the tear this book would be a solid 9.2 IMHO. Still a very nice book without question. What is the page quality like? It look's like it would have a legitimate shot at white pages!?

 

 

Thanks for the help.

 

The pages are snow white...almost as if it was printed yesterday.

[Jaymole]

8.0 perhaps 8.5. Does CGC downgrade for miscut books? I'm not sure. In any case it's a beautiful copy. What is your asking price?

 

I have no idea what to price it due to the tear...I don't think I would want to sell it at a 8.0 price point, which means I probably won't/can't sell it. A frustrating book.