Inspired by the Bats 86... PGM Captain America Comics 15

[Hibou]

Old School Grade or Qualified... whichever you chose.

 

This issue is missing a centerfold...

 

(Help!)

 

Anyway...

 

 

 

[Hibou]

... forgot to note that in the upper left corner (FC), that is not a tear but something like a printing crease.

[Flaming_Telepath]

The centrefold is story pages, yes?

 

(Forgive me but GA ain't my strong suit)

[Hibou]

Non story...

[Flaming_Telepath]

Fair (1.0) (thumbs u

[Hibou]

Would CGC 'Qualify' this book without a centerfold?

 

If so... what grade do you think they'd give?

 

Also, If I found a CF and tucked it in, would it become a PLOD as noted with a married CF?

 

I know, I know... too many questions!!!

[Flaming_Telepath]

Is the staining water damage?

[Hibou]

I don't believe so... there is no indication of water.

 

Just age (dust, dirt?).

[Flaming_Telepath]

(thumbs u

 

2.0-2.5, but with a GA bump, might get a Qualified 3.0

[rjpb]

Q 2.5/3.0

[Comicdey]

missing the centerfold....

 

ack....

 

love the cover.

 

I'd call it a poor if it's missing story pages...fair if it's missing non story pages.

 

Of course if the cover was complete and looked real nice and it was a timely, I'd likely have a tough time selling it for anything less than a decent percentage of good.

[Bat-Man]

Qualified would be if it was missing 1 ad page. But if it's missing the entire centerfold and especially if those are story pages.

 

It's going to be a .5 - don't know if you plan to slab it but don't!

 

Seeing how nice it is, even though it's a .5 "Poor", you can still most likely get Fair 1.0 to Fair/Good 1.5 value when you sell it!

[Hibou]

Thanks... I'm still going to hang onto it and hope to someday find that centerfold!