• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Most valuable Golden age comic

Started by Comicduck-migration,

25 posts in this topic

adamstrange

adamstrange

Posted
Posted

came across a Detective Comics 29 CGC 9.6 and would gather this would

be the most valuable comic in Golden age books.

 

It is probably the most valuable Detective 29.

Is it better than the Dentist`s copy of Detective 29?

since the dentist had them side by side and chose his copy (presumably the mile high) we have to "assume" it is as nice or nicer, I would guess (shrug)

 

Actually, when I got the Detective Comics 29 Allentown from Dave, he told me the Allentown was much better. He actually had already sold the MH copy and kept the AT copy, but when we did our deal, he got the MH copy back.

Why?

Sometimes you just have to settle for the Church copy. :baiting:
Link to comment
Share on other sites
cheetah

cheetah

Posted
Posted

came across a Detective Comics 29 CGC 9.6 and would gather this would

be the most valuable comic in Golden age books.

 

It is probably the most valuable Detective 29.

Is it better than the Dentist`s copy of Detective 29?

since the dentist had them side by side and chose his copy (presumably the mile high) we have to "assume" it is as nice or nicer, I would guess (shrug)

 

Actually, when I got the Detective Comics 29 Allentown from Dave, he told me the Allentown was much better. He actually had already sold the MH copy and kept the AT copy, but when we did our deal, he got the MH copy back.

Why?

Sometimes you just have to settle for the Church copy. :baiting:

 

Slumming it with Edgar Church. The depths to which some people will sink...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
tth2

tth2

Posted
Posted

came across a Detective Comics 29 CGC 9.6 and would gather this would

be the most valuable comic in Golden age books.

 

It is probably the most valuable Detective 29.

Is it better than the Dentist`s copy of Detective 29?

since the dentist had them side by side and chose his copy (presumably the mile high) we have to "assume" it is as nice or nicer, I would guess (shrug)

 

Actually, when I got the Detective Comics 29 Allentown from Dave, he told me the Allentown was much better. He actually had already sold the MH copy and kept the AT copy, but when we did our deal, he got the MH copy back.

Why?

Sometimes you just have to settle for the Church copy. :baiting:

But he had his pick of both! Will not compute, will not compute! :ohnoez:

 

Plus he had already set the precedent by dumping his MH Detective 27 for the AT copy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rob_react

rob_react

Posted
Posted

came across a Detective Comics 29 CGC 9.6 and would gather this would

be the most valuable comic in Golden age books.

 

It is probably the most valuable Detective 29.

Is it better than the Dentist`s copy of Detective 29?

 

Reductio ad Dentistum. This is akin to Godwin's Law of invoking the name of Hitler in all online discussions, except it applies to Golden Age books.

 

lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing