PGM: ASM #20

[sk8dima]

The third book from Mycomicshop, which I discussed at this forum about month ago.

 

Some of you may know the MCS's grade, but I still won't list it untill there are some replies in this thread, so they won't be affected by that grade.

 

I wanted to do smth with the back cover, but then decided it would do bad to the book, so black-marker W will probably stay. But if you know some methods of cleaning it, please list them here, they will be highly appreciated.

 

ASM 20:

 

[sk8dima]

C'mon! Post the grades, No love for Scorpey?

[Hibou]

Actually, that's one of my favorite ASM covers.

 

From Smartphone I'd say 4.5 / 5.0.

[Boboset]

4.5

[NuffSaid57]

VG/F

[sk8dima]

Wow, these are definitely optimistic grades you guys giving. I thought that marker would kinda lower the grade more.

[divad]

Looks like a straight 4.0

 

The marker on the BC is mostly irrelevant in this grade.

[ARK]

4.0 also.

[sk8dima]

Ok, the grade at mycomicshop was 2.5, which is now strange after all those guesses.

[Hibou]

Wow... take a look at the X-men 1 from the Nik grading contest and then give us your opinion of your ASM 20.

 

Unless there's a hidden flaw somewhere, I can't see that as a 2.5... :shrug:

[Hibou]

Here...

 

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=4572303#Post4572303

[sk8dima]

ASM 20 definitely looks better than the x-men book, so i just can't understand why they lowered the grade. it seems to me that all the books, I've bought off Mycomicshop are in better grades than in their desriptions. Kinda strange.

[Conan_Aficionado]

nice buy, it certainly presents very well in the scan, definitely looks better than a 2.5.

CGC IT!!!

 

 

[divad]

Ok, the grade at mycomicshop was 2.5, which is now strange after all those guesses.

 

Which is why the disclaimer:

 

A forum dedicated solely to asking forumites to guesstimate the grade of book from a scan. NOTE: GRADING FROM A SCAN IS NOT RELIABLE, it's just interesting.

 

[divad]

ASM 20 definitely looks better than the x-men book, so i just can't understand why they lowered the grade. it seems to me that all the books, I've bought off Mycomicshop are in better grades than in their desriptions. Kinda strange.

 

Are you a Moscovite shill for Mycomicshop.com?

[sk8dima]

Are you a Moscovite shill for Mycomicshop.com?

Now you know too much...

 

nice buy, it certainly presents very well in the scan, definitely looks better than a 2.5.

CGC IT!!!

If only I could cgc here in Moscow