PGM - Amazing Fantasy 15 - Grade is IN!

[Spider-Dan]

I just got this book, and am debating on sending it back.

 

Plenty of pics and a few scans to look at

 

Everything is complete and attatched. The cover is still att at the back of the top staple, but not the front

 

Any thoughts would be appreciated

[Spider-Dan]

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Comicdey]

Depends on what grade you bought it at, but I'd say 2.5. It looks fresher than my old copy so it could be a 3.0.

 

I sold this one as a 2.0, with the likelyhood of 2.5 once the piece off the back was taped back on. Guess what, it slabbed at a 2.5 and it's changed hands a few times already.

[Point Five]

I'd guess 3.0.

 

 

[oakman29]

2.5/3.0 Whats wrong with it,looks pretty cool to me!

[Boboset]

2.5

 

What was it listed as?

[Junkdrawer]

http://cgi.ebay.com/Very-Rare-Amazing-Fantasy-15-Comic-/190510367754?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item2c5b4d840a

 

looks like you paid 2.5 ~ 3.0 money for it (thumbs u

[divad]

Depends on what grade you bought it at, but I'd say 2.5. It looks fresher than my old copy so it could be a 3.0.

 

I'd go along with this, leaning towards a 3.0

 

Certainly no higher.

[divad]

Seller seems to pass the "smell" test

[oakman29]

For 3800 dollars for a 2.5/3.0 book,you made out O.K.

[divad]

For 3800 dollars for a 2.5/3.0 book,you made out O.K.

 

I don't think so - that seems a tad high to me

[oakman29]

here's a price on Clink for a 2.0

Price: $4,450

Publisher: MARVEL

Condition: CGC 2.0 GD

Page Quality: Cream to Off-White Pages

Here's a price on Clink for a 3.5(sorry no 3.0s)

Price: $6,700

Publisher: Marvel

Genre: Super hero

Condition: CGC 3.5 VG-

Page Quality: Off-White Pages

[Spider-Dan]

For 3800 dollars for a 2.5/3.0 book,you made out O.K.

 

I don't think so - that seems a tad high to me

 

I agree - I was hoping for a 3.5, but it doesnt seem like it has a chance.

[Spider-Dan]

here's a price on Clink for a 2.0

Price: $4,450

Publisher: MARVEL

Condition: CGC 2.0 GD

Page Quality: Cream to Off-White Pages

Here's a price on Clink for a 3.5(sorry no 3.0s)

Price: $6,700

Publisher: Marvel

Genre: Super hero

Condition: CGC 3.5 VG-

Page Quality: Off-White Pages

 

Thanks (thumbs u

 

I saw that, but no solid sales

[Junkdrawer]

here's a price on Clink for a 2.0

Price: $4,450

Publisher: MARVEL

Condition: CGC 2.0 GD

Page Quality: Cream to Off-White Pages

Here's a price on Clink for a 3.5(sorry no 3.0s)

Price: $6,700

Publisher: Marvel

Genre: Super hero

Condition: CGC 3.5 VG-

Page Quality: Off-White Pages

 

Thanks (thumbs u

 

I saw that, but no solid sales

Ebay 3/14/11 CGC 3.0 $4450

Ebay 3/20/11 CGC 3.5 $4555

[oakman29]

here's a price on Clink for a 2.0

Price: $4,450

Publisher: MARVEL

Condition: CGC 2.0 GD

Page Quality: Cream to Off-White Pages

Here's a price on Clink for a 3.5(sorry no 3.0s)

Price: $6,700

Publisher: Marvel

Genre: Super hero

Condition: CGC 3.5 VG-

Page Quality: Off-White Pages

 

Thanks (thumbs u

 

I saw that, but no solid sales

Ebay 3/14/11 CGC 3.0 $4450

Ebay 3/20/11 CGC 3.5 $4555

 

Then Spider-Dan with an Ebay sale of 4450 for a cgc 3.0,your 3800 seems like a bargain.

[etanick]

it is a keeper with nice PQ and a good price or you can just sell it to me for the same price

[Spider-Dan]

Thanks everyone! maybe I'll re-Ebay it and see if I can make a couple dollars

[Spider-Dan]

Just wanted to update those who guessed

 

Just got the grade from CGC today - 3.0 C/OW

 

Thanks again (thumbs u

[Comicdey]

Depends on what grade you bought it at, but I'd say 2.5. It looks fresher than my old copy so it could be a 3.0.

 

I'd go along with this, leaning towards a 3.0

 

Certainly no higher.